Aussie aid workers get boots muddy in PNG
03 December 2010
BY ILYA GRIDNEFF
AAP - AUSTRALIAN AID to PNG is going back to the future with health patrols to isolated villages retracing steps made more than 60 years ago when Australia brought the New World to locals.
Patrol officers, known as Kiaps, were the young Australian officials who often trekked for days in the harsh PNG environment spreading notions of government and law and order to villagers who had never seen white faces before.
While a product of bygone colonial era, the Kiaps brought much-needed health supplies, new tools, provided basic education and prolonged villagers' life expectancy.
The reality now for the majority of PNG villagers is that consecutive PNG governments since independence in 1975 have failed to deliver in these areas despite huge resource revenues.
Provincial governments and local level governments also struggle to provide the most basic of essentials to PNG's six million people, of which 85% live in rural subsistence farming settings.
With the Kiap now a distant memory and Canberra wanting to avoid any accusation of "paternalism" towards its former territory, PNG is now filled with swarms of highly paid advisers and consultants who rarely get their boots muddy or leave their air-conditioned Port Moresby offices.
The experts have no shortage of goodwill plans, development strategies and policies to get PNG on track, but despite billions of dollars in aid and decades of government 'capacity building', PNG languishes with some of the world's worst social, health and education indicators.
But late last month, in a significant shift of approach, an Australian group comprising a special forces soldier and government doctor and nurse team helped PNG Defence Force (PNGDF) medics treat 206 people for various ailments in the Goilala District, Central Province.
The Australian aid agency, AusAID, sponsored the mission, along with three previous treks.
In pouring rain, the team trekked for a week through the rugged Owen Stanley ranges doing everything from immunising children to treating cuts and blisters and providing medicines for arthritis, malaria and intestinal worms.
Goilala district administrator Titus Girau, who trekked with the team, said it was inspiring not just for local administrators but for villagers who rarely see outsiders.
"When I was a boy going to school in the '70s we had regular Kiap patrols in the district but in the 80s and early 90s much of this stopped because the government just couldn't do it.
"This recent effort really helps to lift morale of the district.
"Health and education is vital in the rural setting and sadly we've failed to provide these basic services but this patrol motivates the district and administrators to get on top of the issue," he said.
Mr Girau said the lack of basic infrastructure such as roads and electricity kept villagers stuck in a time warp.
"How can things improve when the most basic of human rights or living standards don't exist?" he said.
Head of AusAID in PNG, Stephanie Copus-Campbell, said Australia's support for foot patrols was part of a "significant shift" in the agency's approach to helping the PNG government provide better services.
"We are sharpening our focus to work more directly on the ground, there is a significant reorientation to work at the sub-national (government) level to see on the ground results," she said.
Ms Copus-Campbell said the shift was part of a gradual policy change but acknowledged it was also in response to this year's independent review recommending Australia focus on where it could make the biggest difference.
The report also found "widespread dissatisfaction" from both sides with Australia's annual $457 million PNG aid program and has since resulted in a third of all advisers being cut.
"We are focused on achieving results, and my job is to ensure we use our resources and expertise to have better outcomes," she said.
"There is no point in having aid posts in remote areas if they are not manned or stocked with drugs, these sort of patrols build capacity in the provincial and local governments to fulfill their role and to revitalise health in the rural setting," she said.
She said four foot patrols had been held in Central Province so far, and there were plans to trial similar approaches in other provinces.
There is a simple fact in PNG which up to now seems to have been missed by AusAID; that is, if you want something done the only way to do it is to do it yourself. This is one reason why the old kiaps were effective.
It is no good giving someone else a bag of money, going away and expecting it to be done when you get back. It never happens. You have to stand over people and make sure they do exactly what you want.
This is no disparagement of PNG workers, it is a universal truth and, happily, there are exceptions to the rule.
AusAID should now be sacking all the consultants and administrators and looking to recruit good people used to operating on the ground and getting their boots muddy.
We kiaps used to get an annual boot allowance. Maybe someone should also be responsible for checking that homecoming AusAIDers have dirty boots.
What's a little mud on the carpet if they've made something good happen?
Posted by: Phil Fitzpatrick | 10 December 2010 at 09:09 AM
Ilya's story plus pics occupied a full page in Monday's Canberra Times magazine section.
Posted by: Don Hook | 07 December 2010 at 10:41 AM
Great to see some common sense coming into AusAID.
A program which Ms Copus-Cambell should consider as worthwhile is one which trains village women, especially from remote areas, in the basic skills of midwifery.
A program was highlighted on BBC World where women were trained as midwives and equipped with basic equipment to carry out births in a village environment. The cost of the kit was around K1,000 for each midwife.
After training the women returned to their villages to help village women during childbirth.
This program according to the BBC has been extremely successful in Africa, India and Bangladesh. May be some one could contact the BBC for further Info.
Posted by: Terry Shelley | 06 December 2010 at 01:27 PM
Wakai wei dre ambai!
Posted by: Peter Kranz | 06 December 2010 at 12:56 PM
AusAID - We want more kiaps in the districts. The PNG government system is not working, it is only serving those in it.
AusAID money must be spent through tourism infrastructure development in the villages and communities, not in Waigani.
Posted by: Ambai Waigl | 06 December 2010 at 12:47 PM
Proof that even dinosaurs can be re-trained if the will is there.
This is absolutely fantastic, and actually brings a glimmer of hope for a new direction from AusAID.
Congratulations, AusAID PNG; we look forward to much more of this grassroots involvement.
Posted by: Peter & Lydia Kailap | 06 December 2010 at 08:24 AM
I do hope that the Australian teams are going to the Defence School of Languages at Laverton to learn Tok Pisin.
Open your mouth mother (opim maus mama).
I would like to look into your mouth (mi laik lukluk insait long maus bilong yu).
That's it (em nau).
Open wider (opim moa).
You look as if you have a rotten tooth (yu luk olsem yu gat tit i sting).
Posted by: Jack Corrie | 04 December 2010 at 10:44 AM
At long last some good news about AusAID. I am sure that such patrols will identify so many other areas that need this type of aid.
The patrol officer of days gonebye did so much to help isolated villages. Since Independence many of these comunities have been ignored.
Now isolated communities such as the Frieda River people are about to be forced fed with mine wastes and I wonder who is going to look out for their welfare? Certainly not the mining company.
Posted by: Trevor Freestone. | 03 December 2010 at 08:17 PM
Good one, AusAID. Continue to close down the air con (in more ways than one) offices in Port Moresby, and listen to the ex-kiaps who still have an abiding interest in the welfare and advancement of Papua New Guineans.
John Fowke, Terry Shelley, Paul Oates and many others are battle hardened, well known and highly regarded by Papua New Guineans.
They have the savvy to get results. Papua New Guineans trust them. I am sure some of them would be prepared to be involved in the design and delivery of aid projects. But the last time I checked, they did not have a PhD. Would that disqualify them ?
And what about encouraging small business in PNG? There is a very substantial amount of industrial clothing and protective equipment imported to PNG.
I suggest a scholarship be awarded to one of the indigenous clothing manufacturers to get the savvy on the standards required and become a fully certified manufacturer and provider.
And some help to present themselves to the mines and other consumers as a preferred supplier of certified clothing and protective equipment.
I find it hard to believe that the standard lime green or orange vest has to be made outside PNG.
Posted by: Peter Warwick | 03 December 2010 at 03:58 PM
Having been a constant critic of the direction of the AusAID program in the past, I have to be fair and acknowledge when they get it right.
This initiative appears to be several steps in the right direction of getting out of the air conditioning and into where the people actually live.
Have AusAID staff been reading PNG Attitude? If so, I wonder whether someone from that area might consider to return our approbation?
Who knows? We may even be able to forge a new partnership?
Posted by: Paul Oates | 03 December 2010 at 02:04 PM
Phil - Right on, mate! And, secondly, I congratulate AusAID on this initiative. It's a pathway leading towards a number of positive possibilities and outcomes. This is really good stuff.
Posted by: John Fowke | 03 December 2010 at 01:15 PM
Hallelujah! Has AusAID finally worked it out?
And the comment about the kiap patrols is gratifying. Treating sick people with simply but efficacious medicines was one of the things that made the job worthwhile - a hell of a lot more satisfying than some retrospective gong.
Posted by: Phil Fitzpatrick | 03 December 2010 at 10:01 AM