PNGDF & ADF treat 700 in remote Papua
New Crocodile award honours Lady Kidu

The seven principles of sovereignty and PNG

BY LEONARD FONG ROKA

STUDYING SOVEREIGNTY and reflecting on its place and impact in society in a Third World country like Papua New Guinea makes me doubt the meaning of being an ‘independent and sovereign’ state.

The concept is well enshrined in the PNG constitution and many other areas such as the Eight Point Plan (1972), the National Goals and Directive Principles (1975) and the current political roadmap, Vision 2050.

All these state that PNG must work towards strengthening and protecting her sovereignty. As Papua New Guineans, we have being moulded by our politicians not to be critical of the political, economic and social changes that occur around us.

This is a culture with very negative impacts today.

Sovereignty is authority over one’s own existence. It can apply to the individual, the community and the nation-state.

Academic Alistair McConnachie states that there are seven principles of sovereignty.  Let me pinpoint exactly where our country stands on these principles.

A sovereign state must develop these principles in the shortest timeframe. Dragging its feet will make the nation weak and vulnerable to external control that may lead to puppet-sovereignty.  In my view this is what PNG is today suffering from.

We celebrate PNG as a resource rich country but in our towns and villages the economic and social indicators depict the worst scenario: poor health services, unemployment, high cost of living, and so on.

I want to discuss my views about PNG’s position in regard to each principle of sovereignty.

(1) Political self-determination

The people of PNG must govern themselves without outside interference, make our own laws in response to our needs, and reject laws that are wrong by our beliefs.

PNG went off track with this pillar with few gains, if any. The founding politicians of PNG and the Australian administration of the pre-independence era ignored the fact that PNG was multicultural and did not educate or empower us to say how and when the independence agenda ought to be addressed.

The colonial masters just dumped us as nobodies into the basket of independence. Papua New Guineans were not prepared for statehood. They danced celebrating the independence in 1975 without understanding what nationhood was all about. We created for ourselves the Australia-dependent syndrome.

Today PNG has the most unpredictable political climate in the South Pacific that keeps inviting the First World to guide us in every step the nation wants to take. People are not exercising concern; both the politicians and the people are too irresponsible in nature.

(2) Economic sovereignty

As I stated, PNG was not prepared for the nationhood. Unequal distribution of wealth was the norm right from the beginning. In regard to this inequality, Bougainvilleans began their resistance movements responding to many factors, but I would only mention the influx of outsiders.

In attaining economic sovereignty immediately before and after independence, PNG had Bougainville Copper contributing the largest share of the national budget. This resource sharing was done at the expense of the Bougainville people.

PNG’s natural resources are today not the people’s but have become a common good for us and the transnational corporations that are based in the First World. With them, we share the land of PNG.

(3) Border control

Any country that cannot control its borders is not sovereign. PNG depends for its national security on her bilateral and multilateral relationships whilst keeping its governmental agencies, for example the immigration office, weak. Corruption enables illegal immigrants to enter and depart as they wish. Our borders are abused and we lack the power of deterrence.

(4) Localisation, not globalisation

The theory of localisation is a core principle of sovereignty because it establishes economic sovereignty. Globalisation destroys the ability of individuals, communities and nation-states to determine their own existence. Sovereignty is also, destroyed.

Globalisation reduces barriers to trade and investment and in the process reduces democratic controls by nation-states and their communities over their economic affairs. PNG concentrates its energies into attracting foreign investors and does not strive to create a conducive environment for local village-level businesses to progress higher in the commercial sector.

(5) Food and water self-sufficiency

The PNG government today is failing its citizens by not being able to control the import of food so as to boost local production. Most of our farmers and industrialists suffer from the high cost of production for their produce which makes their products do very badly at the local markets.

(6) Energy independence

To be a sovereign nation, PNG must be able to attain energy independence. It is perilous to rely on outsiders that often have imperialistic policies to weaken our country. The much lauded LNG project will never bring PNG energy independence when all developers are foreigners and the source of advisors are mostly attached to the World Bank and so on.

PNG, with the longing to quickly taste economic miracles, has by-passed the concept of ‘think big, but start small’. Energy is needed to drive PNG forward, but most people have no access to electricity. PNG is failing in this important area of development.

(7) Self-defence for self-determination

PNG to say she is sovereign must be able to defend herself. PNG, throughout its short history, has been politically and economically shaped by Bougainville, which she considers as her province directed from Port Moresby. Militarily, PNG had a good slap in the face from the Bougainville Revolutionary Army.

PNG is not sovereign in this dimension because all she has for her national security is her foreign relationship mechanism.

I believe some sort of economic and political repentance is needed for Papua New Guinea as a nation in order to save our future generations.

Minimising outside influences and maximising our sovereignty is a must for the betterment of the political system so we build PNG as a powerful country with an absolute say over its people and land.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Leonard Roka

Brothers - You and I are thinkers, but it is the man we mandated into the parliament who ought to be the instrument of change.

But, brothers, I just don't know who is man enough to sacrifice and say 'no' to external parasites?

I know there is a way, I dream of arming myself with people-power, first, then remove the current unrealistic government system.

Steve Gallagher Darong

I think in theory, PNG is sovereign but in practice it is like a puppet. Foreign developed nations control our politicians through bribery because our politicans desire material wealth rather than serving the people. They want money, luxury houses and cars to name a few.

The money they get each fortnight does not satisfy their needs. They need more, as a result they accept corrupt payments from foreign developed nations. By doing this, they undermine the sovereignty of PNG.

This nation need strong leaders, transparent and not individualist but socialist who love the people who are suffering today because of political corruption.

PNG must come up with a policy that, when people want to be a politican, they must sign an oath:

"I will serve my people and my nation with honesty, I will not involve in business, make my fortune from people's money. I will be held accountable for my action and, if found guilty, I will face the hard penalty depending on the nature of crime I committed against my country and people I promised to serve with honesty."

Well, this may be difficult to do because everybody has his or her personal interest apart for his role and also it is difficult because the current democratic government will not do this.

That's is the reason I am always thinking that a military coup or a revolution is possible.

There is a need for political reform, to rewrite the constitution and change the political system to socialist system. PNG needs to be a republic - the Social Democratic State of PNG (SDSPNG).

Give autonomy to different regions, NG Islands, Momase, Papua, Highlands and Southern. We must do this because we cannot eradicate corruption if we continue with the old and invalid system.

New governments can be formed but the system will be the same. Only a few will become rich overnight while the majority will suffer.

And when all our resources are extracted by foreigners for their use we will face a bloody revolution. We may die but our children will do it.

We have been ruled by the minority power holders for years and enough is enough.

If we do not act now, when? Or we might be late.

Icarus

Leonard - As a poet I share some of your sentiments of doubt in the misconceived notions of sovereignty we cling to.

Some time ago I started a sketch with the title, 'Sovereignty? Go hang yourself!'

You've written about some important aspects worth thinking about.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)