Norm Liddle, engaging, likeable, occasionally stoned
Literature: The loneliness of the long-distance writer

Rio Tinto faces war crimes allegations over Bougainville

Lasslett_KrisKRISTIAN LASSLETT | Green Left Website

BRITISH-AUSTRALIAN MINING GIANT Rio Tinto is seriously contemplating reopening its Bougainville copper and gold mine, Reuters reported on 7 February.

The company's Bougainville operation was forcefully closed down in November 1988 by traditional landowners who objected to the mine’s environmental and social effects.

A bloody civil war ensued, which took up to 20,000 lives on an island of 175,000 people. The war crimes committed by government security forces in the conflict were horrific.

Bougainvillean nurse, Sister Ruby Mirinka, recalled, “One of the victims was a 24-year-old pregnant woman. Shot dead by the PNG soldiers, her abdomen was then cut open to remove the foetus. The dead foetus was then placed on the chest of the dead mother for all to see — as a warning.”

Rio Tinto stands accused of being complicit in these atrocities.

In a US class action launched under the Alien Tort Statute, Bougainvillean landowners maintain that Rio Tinto’s subsidiary, Bougainville Copper Limited (BCL), supplied the military with trucks, fuel, accommodation, storage facilities, mess halls, communications equipment and secretarial services.

These allegations were featured in a hard-hitting Dateline report aired on SBS TV in 2011.

In response, company executives adamantly denied complicity. They claimed Rio Tinto’s equipment was commandeered by the defence force after the mine had been abandoned.

BCL director Sir Rabbie Namaliu told The Australian on 16 July 2011: “To suggest that Rio did it deliberately is factually wrong. When I heard about those claims, I thought the whole thing was rather unfair.”

Namaliu was prime minister of PNG from 1988 to 1992. Amnesty International said PNG forces stationed in Bougainville during this period took part in extra-judicial killings, village burnings and the rape of women.

Namaliu is hardly an uncompromised source.

There are other problems with his account. For example, I interviewed eight senior managers who worked for BCL during 1987-1992. They were confident the company did supply the defence force with the aforementioned equipment.

One manager told me: “We did everything they [PNG security forces] asked of us to make their life more comfortable, and better able to manage through, with transport, communications, provisions, whatever, fuel.

“You know, we gave them everything, because as a far as we saw it we were hoping that they were going to solve the situation, so we could start operating again. So we supported them every way we could.”

Perhaps BCL was unaware of the ends to which this logistic support would be applied? Well, its executives seem fairly cogent on this front too.

One manager recalled: “These guys [PNG security forces] were ignorant thugs with guns. Frightened ignorant thugs with guns. Frightened, ignorant thugs with guns a long way from home.”

Another executive remembered surveying the destruction inflicted upon local villages by government forces during April 1989: “Forty, 50 villages, and the crops [were destroyed]. The villages were varying from five or six houses to 20 or 30 houses.”

Naturally, Rio Tinto wants to take advantage of skyrocketing copper and gold prices by dusting off its old South Pacific jewel. I am sure they are attracting a degree of community support from war-weary Bougainvilleans looking to rebuild their shattered island.

That said, communities on Bougainville have yet to be fully briefed on Rio Tinto’s role in defence force operations during the bloody years of 1988-1990. So it would be difficult to argue that this support is based upon informed consent.

Until Rio Tinto commits to full disclosure, any attempt to reopen the Bougainville mine will be another corporate blight on the deeply scarred people of this Melanesian island.

Dr Kristian Lasslett is an executive board member of the International State Crime Initiative. The International State Crime Initiative’s multi-media presentation on the Bougainville conflict, which includes BCL memorandums and meeting minutes, can be accessed here


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Neil Yamelu

It will be a hard way around because, since Rio Tinto was the main contributing factor to the creation of civil war, they should think first before operating.

It seems that before they want to operate, they have to fully compensate the landowners first before operating. I think that should be fair enough.

Michael Dom

I suppose that in the end the people of Bougainville will have to decide if they really want the mine restored to operation, then what amount of money they want paid out to them before or after start-up.

When this 'demand' is placed before the company, the managers will decide whether this amount of money meets their expectations for returning a profit to their investors or not.


At least that's my very simple picture.

Leonard Roka

There is more that needs attention.

So far, leaders promote the concept that 'compensation should be done after mine starts production' but people on the ground want 'compensation before operations begin'. Who wins, I am not sure.

My hamlet lost 11 houses and two vehicles plus other valuables; nothing will be done as the trend is going but I don't like that.

To all things: prevention is better then curing!

Bernard Yegiora

Reopening the mine will surely reopen closed wounds.

Michael Dom

Eh, yu noken tok aut nau. Pablik relesens em secret retirement plan bilong mi.

Bai mi sindaun long Cairns na kaikai moni tasol! LOL!

Michael Dom

Shh, brat Keith yu maski funny, mi tok tru ya. Mi liklik mangi tumas.

Bai yumi givim luksave nem long ol biklain ya.

Ol SWEP ting wanem?

Mi ting sapos yumi mekim nais, ol bikman meri bai hammas long sapotim SWEP tu ya, eh laka?

Ating bihain yu nap wok wantaim displa lain oli kolim pablik relesens - KJ

Michael Dom

Oi! Ating bai gavman ino inap givim wanpela Logohu long dispela brata Lasslett!

Orait mi yet givim em:; 'Grand Chief of Green Left Website' - GCGLW.

Na narapela wantok ya, Kemish, bai kisim wanpela luksave tu o?

Ating Crocodile Prize bai givim em nem 'Grand Was Papa billong Pukpuk' - GWPP.

Sapos olsem orait, givim Dame Carol Kidu nem 'Grand Was Mama bilong Pukpuk' - GWMP.

Taim blong yumi yet long givim luksave long ol trupela manmeri save tingim PNG igo pas.

Yupela tok?

Gutpela tingting olsem ol bigman na meri kisim bras ia. Na Michael Dom ken kisim wantaim olsem 'Draipela Papa Bilong Tok Singsing' - KJ

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)