I can only wish
Wished I told you mom

PNG moves to strongly assert its Pacific leadership claims

Julie Bishop and Peter O'NeillJENNY HAYWARD-JONES | The Interpreter, Lowy Institute

PACIFIC Islands Forum foreign ministers met in Sydney late last week as the spotlight of regional attention focused on the Pacific Games being hosted by Papua New Guinea. Port Moresby hosted a stunning opening ceremony on 4 July.

It was one of several events this year which the PNG government, and in particular prime minister Peter O'Neill, will use to project the country's growing prominence in the region.

Papua New Guinea will also host the Pacific Islands Forum leaders' summit in September along with celebrations on the occasion of 40 years of independence from Australia.

Mr O'Neill sought to inspire the region in his address at the opening ceremony of the Games, saying the event would bring strong bonds between people, teams and nations.

He promised that the world-class facilities PNG had built for the Games would benefit the region for 'generations to come' and said with 'global economic growth centred on our part of the world' it was a 'great time to live in the Pacific'.

In the lead-up to the Games, Mr O'Neill has been busy bolstering his regional leadership credentials. At the biennial Melanesian Spearhead Group (MSG) Leaders' summit in Honiara on 25 June, he brokered the admission of Indonesia as an associate member of the group, 'representing the five Melanesian Provinces in Indonesia'.

The United Liberation Movement for West Papua (ULMWP) had applied for membership too, an initiative supported by civil society groups across Melanesia. West Papuan hopes of securing full membership had been high following an impassioned speech by the MSG summit host and new chair, Solomon Islands prime minister Manasseh Sogavare.

But it was Mr O'Neill's formulation which won the day, and the ULMWP was instead accorded the status of an 'observer member representing Melanesians living abroad.' O'Neill's position is that there is no collective voice among the West Papuan political movements so it is not appropriate for a group that is not elected to represent West Papua at the sub-regional level.

Mr O'Neill broke news of this decision via a Facebook post before the MSG leaders addressed a press conference or released their communiqué in Honiara. This was important.

That he made his announcement separately and not in concert with the other leaders suggests he wanted to demonstrate his own role in brokering the outcome.

Given that so much of the advocacy for the West Papuan cause is now conducted via social media channels (including in Papua New Guinea), announcing the MSG's decision on Facebook also helped Mr O'Neill show he is in touch with his constituency.

Mr O'Neill had already promised Papua New Guinea's support for Indonesia's associate membership during President Joko Widodo's visit to Port Moresby on 11-12 May. He followed up by announcing the proposal at the Pacific Leaders' Meeting in Japan on 22-23 May.

Mr O'Neill made it clear in Japan that Pacific Island countries had to deal with the Indonesian President and elected leaders of the Indonesian provinces with Melanesian populations if they wanted to see social conditions for West Papuans improve.

He also set a tone for his expectations about how Pacific Island countries should deal with 'issues such as climate change, asylum seekers, West Papua' and their interactions with each other, stressing that 'playing emotional politics through the media is not the way to manage international issues in the modern world.'

PNG has further promoted its leadership through a series of bilateral initiatives in the region. Mr O'Neill wants to bestow the region's elder statesman, long-serving Samoan Prime Minister Tuilaepa, with PNG's highest award, the Order of Logohu, during the Pacific Islands Forum leaders' meeting.

Papua New Guinea provided disaster relief to Vanuatu following Cyclone Pam in April, including a $2.5 million aid package and an assessment team. The PNG government is delivering a five-year development assistance program worth about $49 million to Solomon Islands.

Most of the credit for PNG’s new leadership role in the region should go to prime minister O'Neill. He has made a number of important speeches and interventions in 2015 both at home and abroad that are clearly focused on building and securing recognition of PNG's reputation as a regional leader and projecting his views on how PNG and its Pacific neighbours should interact on the global stage.

PNG is by far the largest Pacific Island nation in terms of population size, GDP and land size, and arguably more deserving of recognition as a regional leader than Fiji, which has historically played that role.

But PNG's national development challenges are so much more significant in scale than those faced by any other island nation in the region.

It is far from guaranteed that the prime minister can rely on support from his ministers, government agencies and the public, all of whom are necessarily more focused on domestic priorities, to reinforce his regional leadership ambitions.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Peter Kranz

Australia's minister for foreign affairs Julie Bishop agreed to meet privately with West Papuan activist Peter Elaby on 2 August on condition that no photos, recording devices or flags were present (report by Peter Elaby):

"On the morning of August 2, 2015, our group of Free West Papua supporters attended a fundraiser in Darwin as the key speaker was Australian Foreign Affairs minister Julie Bishop. We asked the ministerial advisers if she could meet us to discuss the human rights situation in West Papua...

The minister replied "The Australian government can't do anything to help the human rights issues in West Papua because we respect Indonesian sovereignty over West Papua." In addition she said "The Australian government is sure that the issue of human rights in West Papua can be solved with consultation with the Indonesian government".


Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)