K90M owed to Oro and Milne Bay people ‘disappears’
This week's PNG budget faces extraordinary revenue collapse

O’Neill safe for now, but still mired in corruption allegations

JENNY HAYWARD JONES | The Interpreter, Lowy Institute | Edited

PAPUA New Guinean prime minister Peter O'Neill comprehensively headed off a motion of no confidence in parliament last week over corruption allegations.

O'Neill's assertion that his government is stable and will “continue to provide stability” ahead of handing down a difficult budget next week is convincing, particularly as he won a vote of confidence 78 votes to two.

But doubts remain about his government's commitment to the rule of law and freedom of speech.

I wrote about the O'Neill government's apparent lack of respect for the rule of law in June 2014. At that time, prime minister O'Neill had avoided an arrest warrant issued relating to his alleged connections to fraudulent payments from the PNG Finance Department to Paraka Lawyers.

This matter has continued to reverberate. In July this year former Police Commissioner Geoffrey Vaki was found guilty of contempt of court for failing to execute the 2014 arrest warrant against the prime minister and sentenced to three years in jail.

In August, two PNG detectives with the National Fraud and Anti-Corruption Directorate, Chief Superintendent Mathew Damaru and Chief Inspector Timothy Gitua, brought contempt charges against new Police Commissioner Gari Baki for alleged interference with an arrest warrant that had been issued for Treasury Secretary Dairi Vele on charges of official corruption relating to decisions of the prime minister.

Vele won a stay against the warrant in July, pending a court decision on setting aside the warrant.

Commissioner Baki then began an investigation into Damaru and Gitua and issued an arrest warrant against them.

Two Australian lawyers, Greg Egan and Terence Lambert, who were joining the legal team acting for Damaru and Gitua, were denied entry to PNG in late September. They believed this to be politically motivated.

A week later the National Court of Justice overturned the ban imposed by the PNG Department of Immigration and the two lawyers were permitted entry.

The arrest warrant against Damaru and Gitua was stayed by the National Court in October and Baki was restrained from further investigating the detectives and their lawyer in a case which cast doubt on Baki's commitment to police impartiality.

The government also sought to suspend Chief Magistrate Nerrie Eliakim in early October. Eliakim is the magistrate who issued the arrest warrant against the prime minister. The government insists its move to suspect Eliakim is related to complaints received about her performance rather than her involvement in the prime minister's case.

In a further twist last week, Supreme Court Judge George Manahu dismissed the application of Attorney-General Ano Pala to have an arrest warrant against him stayed.

Pala is alleged to have conspired with Finance Minister James Marape, prime minister O'Neill and others to defeat the course of justice in relation to the investigations into the Paraka Lawyers payments.

Importantly, the judge said the power of police to investigate and arrest should not be interfered with, that criminal matters do not recognise the status of a person in the community and that being a minister and the chief legal adviser to the government is irrelevant.

In other words: no-one is above the law.

Assistant Police Commissioner Thomas Eluh, perhaps fearing another lawsuit, has called for Pala to  hand himself in for questioning at the National Fraud and Anti-Corruption Directorate office, declaring 'we cannot be going around looking to arrest a national leader'. Eventually Pala handed himself in later in the week – he had been busy attending parliament.

This convoluted web of legal processes which the government has woven has created a public perception that it has something to hide.

The prime minister has encouraged this perception through his unwillingness to engage with critics.

His government has cracked down on 'improper use' of the internet, with new laws imposing fines and jail sentences for placing 'offensive' or 'false' information online – apparently targeting social media activists who have been very critical of the government.

The prime minister decided in August that Australian journalist John Garnaut and former Treasury official Paul Flanagan were no longer welcome in PNG because of their criticism of his government's budget management.

A peaceful public protest against the prime minister in Port Moresby at the beginning of last week, which drew only small numbers, provoked a disproportionate reaction from the police.

Why a leader with a parliamentary majority that would be the envy of prime ministers the world over should be sensitive about a few critics on social media, an Australian economist and a journalist is curious.

Prime minister O'Neill's ability to maintain his dominance is not as easy now as it was at this time last year.

The dramatic fall in commodity prices, consequent budgetary challenges and the El Nino drought threaten his capacity to deliver promised nationally significant reforms such as free education and healthcare, and maintain the District Services Improvement Program under which MPs receive grants to administer services and development initiatives in their electorates and which secure their loyalty to the Prime Minister.

O'Neill is also clearly concerned about his legal battles, which ultimately may present the greatest threat to his leadership.

Nevertheless, for the moment, O'Neill remains in a strong position with few realistic competitors for his job.

O'Neill is right that PNG needs a stable government to deal with the challenges facing the nation. But the people of PNG also need a government that respects the rule of law and is confident enough to engage with its critics about the best way to deal with those challenges.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)