Embracing the future dark to see PNG emerge into the light
Simbu people demand resignation of prime minister O’Neill

Has Peter O’Neill become the symbol of all that’s rotten in PNG?


IN AUSTRALIA we talk of the ‘tall poppy syndrome’: the tendency to disparage people who have the gall to do better than the rest of us.

Some other countries have similar practices. In Scandinavia it is known as ‘jante’.

It begins early in life. As kids we used to play a game called ‘king of the castle (and you’re the dirty rascal)’. This involved finding a high point, like the top of the monkey bars in the playground, and fighting each other to reach and stay there for as long as possible.

In Papua New Guinea the tall poppy syndrome manifests itself in the modern aberration of the traditional bigman. When someone attains the status of bigman the name of the game is to bring him down.

In Australia the tallest poppy in the land is the prime minister. A great deal of political effort is put into demolishing him.

The psychology behind the syndrome is not too hard to follow. It is all about jealousy and aspiration. We may not even disagree with what the tall poppy stands for, we just want to take his place.

Tall poppies are quick to recognise when people are after their heads and their respond by battening down and hanging on for dear life, just like the kid at the top of the monkey bars.

However, while the tall poppy stays upright they tend to colour all that goes on around them.

In Australia we even anthropomorphise the place where the tall poppy operates. In business it is ‘head office’. In our politics it is Canberra.

Most often Canberra is used as a pejorative to encompass everything that is wrong with our country. It is a place where the realities of everyday life are the most poorly understood.

Port Moresby has a similar status in the minds of many Papua New Guineans. It hangs like a boil on the underbelly of the country causing most of the pain that people feel and suffer.

Port Moresby and Canberra are places that aren’t really part of the country in which they exist. Strange people who are different to the rest of us live there.

When you stand back to analyse this it is easy to see what is going on. These tall poppies and bigmen, with their nefarious goings on, poison both the image of their position and the place where they practise it.

In most cases only some of us will dislike our tall poppies. This is okay because it is counterbalanced by those who like them. It becomes a problem when most of us dislike them.

Peter O’Neill currently represents, rightly or wrongly, everything that is rotten in Papua New Guinea, including greed, corruption and nepotism. He is seen to have poisoned not only the perception of himself but of Port Moresby too.

Whether this is true or not has yet to be proven but he has, through his intransigence, irrevocably damaged himself and his office. He has tarnished the brand.

People know this; they can recognise desperation and they are manoeuvring for the kill. The sensible thing for him to do now would be to hitch up his wagon and leave town as quick as he can.

If he doesn’t do that there is a real danger that he will bring everything crashing down around him. In this sense he has the future of his country in his hands.

Beyond that the danger lies in Papua New Guinea simply repeating the experience over and over again as more tall poppies reach for their moment in the sun.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Kela Kapkora Sil Bolkin

Peter O'Neill bulldozes to a point where he can't renege on his decisions. He has to soldier on and probably end up like the Il Duce or the Fuehrer.

Marcus Mapen

Dictators are not very different from terrorists because corrupt and unpopular dictators use terrorism and propaganda to stay in power. We all know terrorists are suicidal madmen.

Paul Oates

Unfortunately Marcus, your logic doesn't apply to dictators who having painted themselves into a corner can never accept that they can't find a way out.

If they understood the problem than there wouldn't or shouldn't be the problem in the first place.

There are only two ways this impasse can end. Either cooler heads prevail upon the PM to agree to be interviewed or there could be an escalation or continuation of the present situation with further bad feelings.

The answer is simple.

A compromise must be reached. That is the PNG way. Why can't enough sensible people have PM agree to be interviewed in his own office with both legal advisors to him and the Fraud squad present and the meeting recorded on video?

The facts of the matter can then be investigated and if, as the PM claims, he has nothing anything to worry about, then the matter can be resolved without further disruption to the nation and no loss of face for the PM or his Office.

The fact that the PM says the legal firm involved in the matter hasn't been charged is a good question? Why is this so? Possibly it's because he hasn't been questioned and the facts revealed? Therefore, why not settle the matter once and for all and allow the facts to be known?

So who could put this potential solution to the PM? Surely in the interests of the nation, perhaps the Chief Justice and the Governor General might suggest this as a solution?

Marcus Mapen

What goes up must come down. That is the law of gravity. That’s God’s (or nature's) law and therefore will never change. No desperate leader or government can change this law.

Even planes that fly high up must come down and land on an airstrip. Whether it crash lands and kills everyone on board (including the pilot) or lands smoothly is entirely in the hands of the man in control. Only a suicidal madman will allow his plane to crash.

Robin Lillicrapp

I suppose the eradication of this political and social dysfunction lies somewhat in the hands of an erudite minority awakening a slumberous "silent majority."

Bravo to the student protests and obviously rising concern at regional levels.

Couple that with the power of penmanship evidenced among PNG Attitude contributors and open doors of opportunity for future leadership aspirants are in clear view.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)