Bangladeshi man burned to death as election warfare continues
PNG women shine at Sunshine Coast literary festival

Voices of independence: Echoing back with nothing new to say

MichaelMICHAEL DOM | AKA Kassandra Komplex, Icarus, Assistant Pig Keeper

IN Samoa there are many people who recall, with only partly contrived awe, that some of their early national missionaries were eaten by New Guineans.

While holidaying there recently, I gladly explained to a few people who asked me about this event that “we ate only the bad ones”. But maybe I should not have been so glib.

It’s a relatively inoffensive question, I suppose. However the agenda the query relates to – reports that PNG people are unbaptized, uncivilized, tribal cannibals – is a familiar frustration to many of us.

We’ve been independent for more than four decades and still we get these “negative images / printed in the media” about our far gone past.

But there’s still this hazy image projecting itself through the mists of time and into the casual meet-and-greet conversations wherever Papua New Guineans roam abroad.

The Western media tells lies about cannibalism in PNG. The guy who ate a new born baby was actually possessed by an evil spirit. The burning of Leniata in the centre of a town market place was not an act of savagery because she was a Jezebel and the whole community witnessed it, and besides she wasn’t eaten. Mt Hagen town will rise from the ashes and ruins and become the Turkey of the highlands. God wills it!

If such news stories capture the attention of international media and social network audiences, then it is little wonder the cannibalism question also pops up in the casual remarks of folks in more elevated circles.

Turnbull: “Hey, Pete, your people aren’t going to eat me when I arrive in PNG are they?”

O’Neill: “No way bro. You’re not that appetising.”

Turnbull: “Oh, that’s good, I suppose. What about those boat people on Manus?”

O’Neill: “Nah, we can’t eat them because Roy Trivedy is watching. And I tell you what, after this year’s election mess nobody will have an appetite to eat any foreign body, except in the nicest possible way.”

Turnbull: “Pete, you’re a master theft, I mean chef.”

O’Neill: “Watch it mate. You never know who’s in my kitchen cabinet and not even God knows what I might cook up for you. We’ve just had some tribal fights too.”

In truth, most people do know the truth about cannibalism’s long past demise in PNG but those newsworthy tidbits are still an awfully interesting story with which to strike up a conversation.

I often enjoy those little engagements.

That said, our cannibal past did leave a lasting impression in the Samoan psyche and provided my visit there with a distinct and juicy flavour.

While the recollection of historical misadventure may provide a morbidly fascinating anecdote today, it does suggest to me that not much is known about the broader evolution of PNG over a number of generations.

We can help cure this unintentional ignorance by engaging in small talk and transitioning to bigger things.

For example, we can turn the conversation to the Kumuls. Oops, scratch that! It’s rugby union not rugby league that dominates in our island neighbours. And we’re not really in that league, er, union.

PNG on the other hand hosted the biggest and bestest Pacific Games ever, in the whole wide world of sport, ever. Bigly.

It cost bucket loads of money and generated for us, now hang on, we’re still awaiting official confirmation of that and who got how much for what.

I’m sure it must have been up there in the millions for paying off the billions. But anyway, the important thing is we won.

And, in our chat, we can remind our friends that PNG created the Bank of South Pacific, even though we still have to fly via Australia with a transit visa to get to Vanuatu or Samoa to see their local branches.

That’s nothing to do with cannibalism, by the way, despite what you may think of airline food.

Despite our low currency exchange rate and sagging national budget, PNG is the largest economy in the Pacific. And size matters. Ask Pete, our most vertically challenged big-man ever.

And we do get lots of money. We don’t see it, but we know it’s there. Pete spends it for us and borrows it for us too. But so long as there’s a BSP branch nearby, we all good. We got this. We also got 300 LNG ships and counting – “Go tell a passerby / that here by Spartan law we lie”, and lie.

On one occasion, when I took refuge in the National Library in Apia, the same never-ending negative trope seemed to follow me upstairs to the Pacific Collection.  There the small delight I had taken in correcting fake cannibalism news and providing much needed alternative facts ended abruptly.

Relaxing in what I had thought was safety and sanctity going about my favourite pastime of exploring for poems, I came across an exhilarating book that led to hours of rambling, frustrated thought.

When reading the foreword to ‘Voices of Independence: New Black Writing from Papua New Guinea’, I took a step 37 years back in time and arrived exactly at where I am today. Nothing much had changed.

But, having contemplated Ulli Beier’s words of 1980, you decide:

Political events have obviously made a critical examination of colonialism less relevant. Instead, there is already disillusionment with the national government; its conservatism, its easy acceptance of foreign business, its timid stand towards Indonesia, and the resultant “betrayal” of the West Irian freedom fighters. Above all there is disillusionment with the power-hungry bureaucracy and the increasing pompousness and Westernization of the so-called elite.

The writer’s position has become more difficult and more ambiguous since independence. In the late sixties the young angry writers were seen as natural allies by Papua New Guinea’s politicians. The writers then helped them to form public opinion and political consciousness and exercised some influence on the stance of leading politicians. But now the government is sensitive to criticism, and many leading politicians fail to distinguish between issues and personalities.

Writers on the whole have been tolerated rather than encouraged. There are few intellectuals in parliament, and the leaders of the nation are pragmatic men not given to ideologies. Many of the younger people have found the government uninspiring and mildly unsympathetic to their own aims and ambitions, but they have not espoused alternative political ideologies. Mostly the writers have seen themselves as social critics rather than political rebels.

Apia CBD  SamoaDuring the years since self-government many of them have taken an unsentimental look at their own communities, both rural and urban. The unflinching way in which many have learned to look at themselves is one of the healthiest symptoms of Papua New Guinea society today.

At least Ulli ended his foreword on a positive note and one on which I hope the writers, poets, essayists and novelists emerging through the Crocodile Prize also keep heading towards. Moreover, I sincerely hope our new crop of political leaders hear our voices.

We are not the disembodied echoes of a senseless state; we are the independent voices of a free nation.

'Voices of Independence – New Black Writing from Papua New Guinea', edited by Ulli Beier, 1980, St Martin’s Press New York


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Pawa Kenny Ambiasi

As person lone to be a writer one day, I feel obliged in reading your work. I prayer God will help me know the mechanics of writing and I will do one.

Ed Brumby

Poro: This is an excellent piece: I see a new 'career' for you as a socio-political essayist a la the likes of PJ O'Rourke - acknowledging, of course, that you already do so via your poetry.

I remember well the heady days of the late '60s and early '70s when angry young men (and, regrettably, they were mostly men) like John Kasaipwalova et al fostered the flowering of PNG literature - a legacy that the likes of you, Rashmii Bell, Marlene Potoura, Baka Bina, Daniel Kombon, Francis Nii et al are now nurturing.

Michael Dom

Hi Daniel, thanks for your wisdom.

I am excited to hear about the mention in your novel and look forward to buying a copy.

Lindsay F Bond

Michael, may wings mercurial speed your message of tasteless generational monomorphism and geo-mismeasure.

Daniel Kumbon

Thanks for this Michael.

The sad fact is, we must live with some truths and perceptions about us. What our ancestors did, Prime Minister Peter O’Neill or the government does, civil servants do or the behaviour of our people, reflects on the whole country.

The cover girl on my new book just published ‘Survivor: Alive in Mum’s Loving Arms’ is part Samoan and part PNG. Her late father was from Enga province.

The book is her story – how she survived a massacre. The sad facts surrounding the deaths of her parents or how our recent national elections was conducted reflects on the whole country. That is the truth.

Writers are recorders of history. Every piece of writing is a draft copy of a family, village, district or a province. But in actual fact it is the over-all history of the whole country.

I would urge writers to keep writing, enter the lucrative Crocodile Prize competition on offer and record history.

Your writing will definitely end up in a library like Ulli Beier's 'Voices of Independence' for future generations to reflect back on.

And Michael, I mentioned your name in my new book somewhere. The Old Man in one of the stories sits reading a book of poetry by you.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)