PNG fails health check: now E Asia’s worst performing economy
Sixth Manus death signals system in chaos as Oz exit looms

Election 2017: ‘Fraud, violence, intimidation & corruption'

Dr Joe Ketan


NOOSA – Far from being a celebration of democracy, Papua New Guinea’s recent general election provided a toxic banquet of malfeasance, deception, connivance and deadly violence.

Now Western Highlands-born academic Dr Joe Ketan, who spent four months intensively observing the election, has delivered what the Australian Broadcasting Corporation has termed “a scathing assessment” of what transpired.

Dr Ketan, a political scientist and former head of PNG Studies and International Relations at Divine Word University, concluded the election showed PNG “descending into community dictatorship” which "compromised the principles of democracy".

PNG’s democracy had been eroded through malpractice, fraud, violence, intimidation, bribery and corruption, he said.

“The lack of integrity at all levels of state society relations, with loss of trust in government institutions, is a cause for concern,” he said.

Democracy was very fragile and might take hundreds of years to restore as people had “grown thick skin” and were tolerating the current situation.

Dr Ketan accused the PNG electoral commission of “turning a blind eye” to much of what happened.

He said the only hope for PNG was to teach the younger generation not to carry on this cycle of corruption so they could teach their children and the generations to come.

You can listen to Joe Ketan discussing his election report here

Dr Ketan also questioned reports by international observers on the conduct of the election, calling them “very diplomatic”.

His experience varied significantly from their expressed views. As you would expect, prime minister Peter O’Neill built a veneer of triumph around the election, but what proved harder to stomach were the ingratiating and less than candid reports and commentaries offered by Australian and Commonwealth officials.

“The Australian government congratulates PNG, one of our closest friends and partners, on its successful election,” said Australian foreign minister Julie Bishop.

“Our group was of the view that despite the challenges observed with the electoral roll, there were some positive aspects observed, in particular the high voter turn-out and enthusiasm by the people to participate in their democratic process,” reported the Commonwealth Observer Group, pulling many punches.

And Australian senator Linda Reynolds told parliament, “I had the great privilege of representing the Australian government as one of four Australian observers to the 2017 PNG elections. I would like to start by warmly congratulating Papua New Guinea on the successful conduct of their ninth election since independence.”

The report of this delegation has still not been tabled in parliament. Neither has there been any report on election-related deaths, estimated to be more than 100, tabled in the PNG parliament.

And we should constantly remind ourselves that, while there are 111 seats in the PNG parliament, not a single woman representative was elected, a reality the PNG government needs to take substantive steps to correct - preferably through a reserved seats system.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Angela Mandie-Filer

I contested three national election cycles, 2002 in a rural electorate and 2012 and 2017 in an urban electorate located in the nation's capital.

The 2017 election was the most corrupt, violent, and disorganised. Counting in my electorate took six weeks - only completed by bringing in electoral workers from another Province.

My experience also varies significantly from the expressed view of reports by international observers. And yes, with zero women occupying seats in the national parliament, following the 2017 election cycle, women's underrepresentation in parliament is the worst in 25 years.

The Inter-Parliamentary Union ranked PNG 193 out of 193 states that held elections in 2017 & 2018 for having the least number of women in its parliament.

The government is yet to implement the Equality and Participation Law 2011, passed by parliament in 2011 to be implemented in 2012.

Although the parliament is now an all-men show there is still no affirmative action to increase women's representation.

The diplomatic nature of international observers' diagnosis of elections in PNG is not helpful to PNG nor the nearly four million women of PNG.

Bernard Corden

The views expressed by Bishop and Reynolds merely confirm the legitimacy of the current Australian government.

At least Tony Blair, Alastair Campbell and Peter Mandelson et al tried to disguise their deception.

To acquire immunity to eloquence is of the utmost importance to the citizens of a democracy - Bertrand Russell

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)