Our absolutely unbelievable fracturing of language 😠
Diver & planter Harry Brutnall dies at 97: Man of energy & action

The refugee deal - land of the free, but only for a few

Asylum on Manus Island (Eoin Blackwell)
Asylum seekers on Manus Island in 2014 (Eoin Blackwell)


SYDNEY - Last month, after more than four years of suffering, 25 excited and nervous male refugees left Papua New Guinea's remote Manus Island for a new life in the United States.

Left behind are another 800 men - refugees and asylum-seekers - who are wondering if they too will be rescued by the US government or remain in a dead-end limbo while exposed to violence in Papua New Guinea.

"We didn't know if the US deal was real or fake," a refugee from Pakistan told me. He has completed his US interview but is not among the 25 who left for the US.

"Now we know, but I am still so worried. How many will the US take and when? And who will be left behind?"

For more than four years, Australia has warehoused these men in Papua New Guinea in harsh and dangerous conditions.

Papua New Guinea has recognised most of them as refugees who fled persecution in their home countries. They attempted perilous boat journeys to Australia.

Instead of finding refuge there, they have faced violent attacks by Papua New Guinean locals and security forces, inadequate medical care, and uncertainty about their future.

Australia's policy of offshore processing is designed to deter future boat migrants. But Manus Island has not turned out to be a welcoming or safe place for the refugees. Quite the opposite.

I visited Manus Island last week and met men who had been beaten, robbed, and stabbed by young men from the local Papuan community. I met refugee men so paralysed by fear that they rarely leave the guarded centres where they live.

One of them, 35-year-old Jahim (not his real name) from Bangladesh, told me what happened one June morning when he and a friend were in Lorengau town to buy a chicken.

A group of local men cornered them, demanding they hand over their phones and belongings. Initially, Jahim resisted. A man put a knife to his throat. "I was too late in handing over the phone. It's the only way to contact my family. Then he cut me here." He shows me a long scar at his elbow.

Following the attack, Jahim went to the local hospital. He says hospital staff claimed they could not treat him, and only offered him some pain relief. So Jahim took a taxi to the main detention centre on a naval base, which maintains a medical clinic. From there, authorities sent Jahim by plane to Port Moresby hospital for surgery.

Nearly everyone I spoke to had witnessed or experienced violence or theft by local men, usually young, often intoxicated. The night before I arrived, a large group of local youths beat two Afghans near the transit centre.

"I hadn't left the transit centre in three months because I don't feel safe," one of the refugees told me. "I went out and they wanted to fight us. They beat me with sticks, with rocks until I fell down dizzy. They took my phone, my money." His face was still swollen from the beating.

Refugees say Manus police have not held anyone to account for these robberies. Refugees have stopped reporting the cases to the police because of their inaction. Jahim told me, "I didn't tell the police. The police are not listening to us. It's not my country. Now when I see Papuans, I feel scared. I don't come to town."

The Australian government forcibly transferred these men to Manus Island. Now it is forcing them to leave the main detention centre by October 31, and has already started dismantling some buildings. Australian and Papua New Guinean officials say the men must move to a less-secure transit facility closer to town or else return to their home countries.

Supposedly, this is to implement a Supreme Court ruling from April 2015, which ruled detention of the men at the centre unconstitutional, forcing both governments to unlock the gates and provide some freedom of movement. I don't think another forcible transfer is what the judges had in mind.

It is a tragic irony that the only place on Manus Island these men feel safe right now is inside a centre where occasionally soldiers and police have shot at them, where locals once attacked them with machetes and beat them. But that centre, for now, is guarded and provides some security.

Papua New Guinea is not a safe place for any foreigner, but it is especially dangerous for young men without money or connections, many of whom do not speak English and have little experience of living in hostile foreign environments.

However grudgingly, the US government has done Australia a favour by agreeing to resettle some of the men from Manus Island and some of the 1,100 men, women and children from Nauru. But that's no excuse for Australia's inaction about those who remain.

Elaine Pearson
Elaine Pearson

Australia should immediately end offshore processing and resettlement by bringing every one of these men, women and children here to either have their asylum claims processed or if they are refugees, to restart their lives here.

As Australia's partner, the US can help, by insisting that Australia should leave nobody behind in Papua New Guinea or Nauru. It can press Australia to accept offers to take some of the refugees that have been made by other generous third countries like New Zealand.

Every day these men remain on Manus is another day of suffering.

Elaine Pearson is Australia director at Human Rights Watch


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Arthur Williams

I would not be surprised if many these alleged refugees are in fact economic migrants.

Many have paid for long trips by land then sea towards Australia.

Many are unaccompanied by their wives and children.
Many are Muslims yet have failed to seek ‘refugee’ status in the Muslim majority nations of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Malaysia, Indonesia which they consciously passed through toward their intended goal of minority-Muslim Australia.

There have been absurd stories about Manus being hot and or humid. There have been quite a number of pregnancies among Manus island women which show detainees are free to move around Lorengau.

There was uproar in media at ‘Another death at Manus center’ when the truer picture emerged of the guy committing suicide because he was due in court for found having sex with a minor in a Lorengau hotel.

There is no mention of the compensation payout of A$70m (£43m; $56m) by the Australian government to asylum seekers detained in Papua New Guinea which has been approved by an Australian judge.

Also no mention in article about the USA-OZ agreement that allows for up to 1,250 asylum seekers to Australia to resettle in the US.

In return, Mr Turnbull's administration has agreed to resettle people from Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador who have sought asylum in the US.

No doubt there are some genuine refugees among the remaining approximately 1200. The Iranian Kurds would most likely be in that category.

In the UK the safest means of resisting deportation is to claim you are homosexual and would be at risk if repatriated to your Muslim homeland or to avoid similar fate claim you were a Muslim but are now a Christian.

A refugee is an asylum seeker who has been investigated and processed through UNHCR and found to be a person genuinely fleeing from peril. About 90% of the men, women and children on Manus and Nauru were so designated - KJ

Philip Fitzpatrick

PNG really needs a good PR manager.

The job from hell?

Except for a couple of notable exceptions I've never felt unsafe in PNG either Daniel.

It's safer to be a foreigner in PNG than for a local in some places I suspect.

And when I was last in Manus the locals and refugees were getting on quite well together. Manusians, like lots of PNGs can't help but being friendly.

Daniel Doyle

"Papua New Guinea is not a safe place for any foreigner." So, how did I manage to survive forty-two years there, I wonder? And how, in my retirement, I look back and think, "I would do it all again"?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)