We all need to know the interdependence of law & democracy
The battle of Kokoda: Fairness or exploitation on the Trail?

PNG students in China say Facebook ban could be damaging

Fb banned
Is Sam Basil's one month takedown of Facebook for dubious "research" just a precursor to a total ban?

MELISHA YAFOI | Pacific Media Watch

Since this article was written and the Facebook ban story widely reported  around the world, PNG communications minister Sam Basil has walked back from his statement about suspending the social media platform. Basil now says his words were 'taken out of context' and 'not official, just a discussion'.....

BEIJING – Papua New Guinean students studying in Beijing, China, have described the move by PNG communications minister Sam Basil to suspend Facebook for one month as “irrelevant” and damaging for educational communications.

Speaking in a forum, the students expressed disappointment, saying there are more pressing issues that the government needs to address yet it is concerned about legislating freedom of speech for the people.

They said that being outside the country they were able to read information and connecting with family back home as many of the people do not have other social media platforms other than Facebook.

They also said through Facebook leaders were made accountable to their actions and were condemned publicly for their wrongdoing.

“Some people abuse it but the majority use this to express themselves. Why is government so worried about it? They have better things to do than wasting time to FB issue,” Beijing PNG students vice-president Samuel Ray said.

“The real issues are out there. We have police brutality on the rise, car theft, rural urban drift, poverty, deteriorating infrastructure both school, road and health services, drug shortage, TFF [tition fee free] policy not working well etcetera.”

It was also raised that it is obvious that people have already lost their trust in the government. As a result there would be no positive result coming from this temporary suspension.

“Most politicians, top government officials and top shots are always on their toes for being exposed of under the table deals,” the students said.

“Our national media - with due respect to the hard working media team - can sometimes be compromised by the government.

“This leaves social media with no restrictions on people on what they post. A national social network isn’t a solution. The data of citizens shouldn’t rest in the hands of privileged individuals to manipulate.”

An international relations student suggested that PNG’s Communications and Information Technology Department should focus more on things like how to improve network services around the country and work on helping PNG catch up to the digital era rather than trying to keep PNG away from it.

She said shutting down Facebook will not solve anything and trying to analyse its positive or negative impacts was a waste of time and resources.

“The government, instead of choosing to totally shut down Facebook, should innovate ideas on establishing appropriate alternatives especially on the imposition of penalties on those abusive users of this social media platform,” another student said.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Daniel Kumbon

PNG has had leaders before but this current crop is different.

They are like scientists doing experiments ‘in the best interest of the people’ but operating in a vacuum with the people nowhere to be seen.

Governor Parkop has come up with YOGA, Sam Basil wants to ban FACEBOOK, ... Douglas Tomuriesa sides with ILLEGAL LOGGERS, O'Neil keeps on BORROWING, James Marape can't fight to ensure LNG ROYALTIES are paid to his very own people, Justine Tkatchenko seems to like buying MILLION KINA PROPERTIES in Australia.

It’s good APEC will be hosted here in three months so the world can see where PNG is being led to!

Arthur Williams

Wonder who wrote this student complaint about banning Facebook in the PNG story.

The Reporters Without Borders reported at https://rsf.org/en/ranking that China is 176 out of 180 countries in its 2018 worldwide Index of Press Freedom.

Peter Kranz

I think someone told him how difficult it would be. Filter all channels to the outside world? That means all overseas cable links, all satellite connections and all mobile providers. All wind and no shit.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)