We don’t want to be a nation of beggars. Peter O’Neill must resign
Unrest in the highlands exposes deep political divisions

‘My people can’t compete’: China’s influence provokes resentment

Martyn Namorong & Julie Bishop
Martyn Namorong - "My people feel they can't compete."   Julie Bishop - "We want to continue to be the partner of choice."

STAFF REPORTER | South China Morning Post

HONG KONG - In the gritty, steamy streets of Papua New Guinea’s capital Port Moresby, signs of China’s push into the Pacific island nation are inescapable.

A Chinese worker stencils a logo for China Railway Group outside the new national courthouse being buil; China Harbour Engineering Group labourers tar roads under the searing midday sun.

“Little by little they are taking slices of our businesses,” said Martyn Namorong, who campaigns to protect local jobs and communities as China ramps up infrastructure spending in the resource-rich nation, often bringing its own workforce. “My people feel we can’t compete.”

The nation of eight million people is the latest frontier in Beijing’s bid for global influence that’s included building artificial reefs in the South China Sea, a military base in Africa and an ambitious trade-and-infrastructure plan spanning three continents.

China’s thrust into the Pacific islands region, a collection of more than a dozen tiny nations including Fiji, Niue and Timor Leste scattered across thousands of miles of ocean, has the US and its close ally Australia worried.

The region played a key role in World War II and remains strategically important as Western powers seek to maintain open sea lines and stability.

For Beijing, it offers raw materials, from gas to timber, and a clutch of countries who could voice support for its territorial claims.

“We’ve seen a huge surge in China’s state-directed economic investment and mobilisation of an enormous amount of capital in the Pacific which clearly has a strategic intent,” said Eric B Brown, a senior fellow in Asian affairs at Washington-based think tank the Hudson Institute.

“The sovereignty of these nations could be compromised by these predatory economic methods. And that could create a military threat to countries such as Australia and affect the ability of the US Navy and its allies to maintain freedom and order in the Pacific.”

China’s lending practices related to the Belt and Road Initiative have raised concerns among the International Monetary Fund and the Trump administration that poorer countries wouldn’t be able to repay heavy debts.

China has overtaken Japan as Papua New Guinea’s largest bilateral creditor and by the end of the year PNG will owe it well over K6 billion in concessional loans – almost a quarter of its total debt burden.

In April, Standard & Poor’s lowered PNG’s sovereign credit rating to B from B+, citing rising costs of servicing debt that’s climbed above 30% of gross domestic product and is expected to reach 40% by 2021.

While the largesse flowing into the Pacific from Beijing is a fraction of the $350 billion of Chinese aid distributed globally since 2000, it’s still big money for the nations, most with populations under one million.

Hugh White, a professor of strategic studies at the Australian National University in Canberra, says “there’s no doubt” China could seek to establish a military presence in the Pacific in the future, cashing in its influence with “one of these small, vulnerable states.”

“It intends to become the primary power in east Asia and the western Pacific,” White said.

Governments in the region have sought to strike a balance between accepting China’s cash and resisting moves that would raise concern among Western military powers.

Vanuatu in April denied media reports that China had approached it to build a permanent military base in one of its harbours.

The office of PNG’s Prime Minister Peter O’Neill, who’s due to meet President Xi Jinping in China tomorrow, didn’t reply to repeated requests for comment.

When O’Neill visited Beijing in 2016, he pledged support for China’s military build-up in the South China Sea. In December, a month after China promised to construct K11 billion of roads, O’Neill said PNG will continue to be a “staunch partner.”

Beijing’s push into the Pacific islands risks further straining ties with key trading partner Australia – which views the region as its own diplomatic backyard and has been increasingly critical of China’s economic and military muscle-flexing.

During a visit to the region this month, foreign minister Julie Bishop said “we want to continue to be the partner of choice for nations in the Pacific.”

Last week her government signed an agreement to build a new undersea telecommunications cable to the Solomon Islands, squeezing out a bid by China’s Huawei Technologies Ltd.

PNG has traditionally looked to Australia – from which it won independence in 1975 – for a helping hand.

Outside the capital, the nation’s woeful roads network has helped push prices of food staples beyond what many can afford. It’s also struggling with an illiteracy rate of 35%, poor tax collection and endemic corruption.

Australia is still its largest donor, contributing more than three-quarters of total aid and loans compared to China’s 14%. Yet the majority is directed to improving corporate governance, while Beijing has focused on infrastructure and major works.

Nursing a cool drink at a sports club in Port Moresby, British-born business adviser Paul Barker said China was stepping into a vacuum left by the west.

“The government in Beijing has rolled out the red carpet and our leaders seem to be a bit intoxicated by the experience,” said Barker, who’s lived in his adopted nation for more than four decades.

Australia’s assistant trade minister Mark Coulton acknowledged the merits of China’s investment as he sat in one of Port Moresby’s few five-star hotels near the Beijing-gifted convention centre where Apec leaders will meet in November.

“You can’t deny your neighbour if someone is looking to build something they really need,” he said. “Our role is to give the PNG government and people the ability [to] handle influxes of foreign aid like those that are now occurring.”

China’s foreign ministry, which didn’t respond to a request for comment, in April said Pacific island nations weren’t in the “sphere of influence of any country” and called on Australia not to interfere.

Prof Wang Dong - "Scaremongering to think this will lead to military ambition in the Pacific.”

Wang Dong, an international relations professor at Peking University, dismissed concerns that large concessional loans leave nations vulnerable to “debt-trap diplomacy” and said China’s expanded role in the Pacific is a natural consequence of its growing economic clout.

“It’s scaremongering to think this will lead to any military design or ambition in the Pacific,” Wang said in a phone interview from Beijing. “We will see China increase its presence there and it will keep helping these countries build their infrastructure.”

China is in the region to stay, said Jonathan Pryke of the Lowy Institute, a Sydney-based think tank.

“China has entered the Pacific in a significant way,” said Pryke. “It’s upended the status quo and caused anxiety, because no one knows what its end-game is.”


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Bernard Singu Yegiora

I wrote about Chinese soft power and influence a few years ago. Now we are beginning to see tangible changes in the Pacific and the reconfiguration of power.

Interesting times ahead.

Barbara Short

For a small developing country like PNG these huge Chinese loans could become a problem.
The country has not yet reached the stage where village people are able to mortgage their village land for a loan to start up an SME.
Yet here is China lending money to PNG for loans that it may not be able to repay. The concept that they will have to offer some "land" to repay the loan will probably be something they will not accept. What happens then?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)