What should be the values of the people running PNG?
Big health donors defraud patients by ignoring corruption

How China can help save Papua New Guinea’s forests

Governor Gary Juffa
Governor Gary Juffa

GARY JUFFA | The Diplomat

ORO - This summer, my country, Papua New Guinea, became the newest member of China’s Belt and Road Initiative. This global program already spans dozens of countries and represents over a trillion dollars of planned investments in infrastructure development.

Meanwhile, China’s aid to PNG is surging: only recently, it committed around $4 billion to developing PNG’s national road network.

These initiatives mean that bilateral trade is set to increase — but if China does not make significant changes in the way it sources raw materials abroad, the outcome is likely to be a bad one for PNG.

PNG’s forests are among our most valuable natural resources. Some 70% of the country is covered in forests that support hundreds of rare and endemic species, making PNG a ‘megabiodiverse’ country.

These forests are also directly critical to the lives and well-being of most of our people, including the communities in my province. But for decades, we’ve struggled to responsibly manage this vital resource.

The PNG forest sector has long been marked by corruption and illegality, making the timber we produce considered high risk by independent international groups that monitor this. And we’re losing money on it: the policy think tank the Oakland Institute has estimated that tax evasion in the sector may be costing PNG over $100 million per year.

Despite these problems, PNG exports a lot of timber — over three million cubic meters of logs in 2017. Most of that wood is bought by China, where it is made into commodities like furniture and flooring. Research from the watchdog group Global Witness showed that some of these products are ending up in places like the United States.

Although China doesn’t have a law that bans the import of illegal timber, the United States and other major markets like the European Union do, making this trade a risky one for China. In fact, China is falling behind other major economies in not enacting such a law, and continuing to source risky timber from corrupt states around the world.

As the governor of PNG’s Oro Province, where forests have been targeted by logging companies without my consent or that of affected communities, I see many opportunities for our country to learn from China.

The Chinese economy is 700 times the size of PNG’s — but 50 years ago its GDP was not so different from ours today. As China has rapidly developed, it has lifted millions out of extreme poverty, but that development has had profound effects on its environment and the health of its people.

In recent years, the importance of protecting a healthy environment has become apparent in Chinese domestic policy. For example, in 2017, China extended a ban on commercial logging in natural forests to cover the whole of the country.

President Xi Jinping has called for Chinese citizens to defend what he called “ecological red lines”: natural areas that are too valuable to exploit. As Xi puts it, “Lucid waters and lush mountains are invaluable assets.”

I couldn’t agree more. The problem is that while China protects its own environment, its behaviour abroad is driving environmental devastation in countries like PNG.

China has not yet extended its own internal best practices to how it sources raw materials in other countries, which means that illegally produced timber from PNG continues to feed China’s manufacturing sector.

The forests of PNG are a source of wealth not just for our people, but for all of humanity. Our forests store huge quantities of carbon, provide freshwater and local climate benefits, and serve as habitat to extraordinary biodiversity.

They are also central to the way of life of millions of Papua New Guineans. This means that what China chooses to do impacts us all. I call on China to keep illegal timber out of its markets — and help PNG’s forests remain standing.

Gary Juffa MP is the Governor of Papua New Guinea’s Oro Province and Leader of the People’s Movement for Change Party


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Lindsay F Bond

Trying to 'hold the ground', noting drier regions of planet Earth, Marijn Nieuwenhuis (in The Conversation UK) is reported drawing attention to “China…quickly turning into a desert, and…causing problems across Asia”.

As the report states: “Desertification threatens the subsistence of about a third of China's population, especially those in the country's west and north, and could pose serious challenges to political and economic stability.”
See https://www.businessinsider.com/china-is-turning-into-a-desert-and-its-causing-problems-across-asia-2016-5

Any expectancy that China’s “ban on commercial logging in natural forests” (of China) will benefit people of PNG, is more likely a road to disappointment. Anne Thiel and Xiufang Sun suggest the effect may be China “exporting environmental damage to other, more vulnerable countries.”

See https://www.forest-trends.org/blog/chinas-logging-ban/

No doubt China has shown enormous strides in technological capability (equipping rail, road, aeronautics, spacecraft, digital equipment and more) yet clouding by factory smoke and desert dust obscures belief that ecological leadership will be anytime soon seen much less achieved.

Of stunning contrast is the viewing of China’s western desert area from the safety of a high speed rail carriage (for example, Urumqi to Lanzhou is do-able, daily)…life sustained on train not so well on terrain.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)