Is China engaged in ‘debt-trap diplomacy’ in the Pacific region?
Those colonial & kiap times: some coercion, but never repression

As Oz gears up in Manus, China says 'discard cold war thinking'

HMAS Adelaide
HMAS Adelaide arrives in Port Moresby to provide security for the APEC forum next week

ALAN BOYD | Asia Times

SYDNEY - Australian naval vessels have arrived in Papua New Guinea to protect leaders at a summit of Pacific Rim nations next week, giving a foretaste of the newly elevated defence relationship between the two neighbours.

Defence officials confirmed that Australia’s helicopter docking ship HMAS Adelaide is now off Papua New Guinea’s capital of Port Moresby, accompanied by two patrol boats.

They will provide security for cruise ships tethered in the harbour that will house delegates to the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) gathering.

Australian special forces troops have been in PNG for two months preparing security measures around facilities for the 17-18 November summit, which will be attended by US vice president Mike Pence, Chinese premier Xi Jinping and the leaders of 18 other countries.

A series of other meetings held in conjunction with the summit starts on Monday.

About 1,500 Australian service personnel are providing the backbone of the Joint Security Task Force, supported by F/A-18F Super Hornet fighter jets and MRH-90 helicopters. The US is supplying customs vessels, while Indonesia and New Zealand have helped train local police and military.

The operation is mostly aimed at deterring potential terrorist threats, especially for the vulnerable cruise ships, but also sends a firm message of regional solidarity as China flexes its own muscles in the South Pacific and South China Sea.

Canberra and Port Moresby signed an expected deal late last week for Australia to redevelop the Lombrum Naval Base on Manus Island and help expand the Papua New Guinea’s tiny armed forces. China had already made a similar offer.

Established by the US during World War II, Lombrum was occupied by Australian forces from 1946 until 1974, the year when PNG became independent from Australia. It was mostly used for refuelling and as a stores depot.

Keeping China out of the base is important to Australia and the US as Lombrum provides a springboard within reach of a strategic ring of existing installations and with access to shipping lanes in the South China Sea and South Pacific.

The US has naval facilities at Pearl Harbour on Hawaii, Guam, Yokosuka in Japan and in Washington state, while US Marines are deployed in Darwin.

Australia’s western fleet headquarters is near Perth and the navy has bases in Darwin and Cairns. There are also two airforce bases in the Northern Territory, three in Western Australia and one in South Australia.

Lombrum today
Lombrum naval base is to be upgraded under a joint Australia-PNG initiative

How Lombrum will fit into the strategic equation is unclear, as its facilities will still be limited even after the overhaul which will initially improve the wharf.

“It’s a pretty small place and the facilities there wouldn’t take an LHD (landing helicopter dock), for example, but in time I guess we’ll look forward to seeing what the development provides,” Australian chief of navy Michael Noonan said, while adding it was “hugely important.”

If the LHD, with a displacement of 27,500 tons, can’t fit into the base, there is even less room for the Nimitz class of aircraft carriers used in the US Pacific fleet, which displace 102,000 tons – though it might still have a role for deployments of marines in the US Pentagon’s strategic pivot to Asia.

“You can see nothing but potential going forward and we’ll just have to see how the details manifest themselves,” US chief of naval operations John Richardson said. “From the United States navy’s perspective, we look forward to identifying opportunities where we can support that.”

Lombrum will initially be fitted out for four new patrol boats Australia is donating as part of a record US$412 million aid disbursement for PNG in 2018-19, including US$86.5 million for security and logistics during the summit.

PNG, which has only one plane and one helicopter in its defence force, has also reportedly submitted a shopping wish list of military equipment upgrades.

Australia is likely to base frigates and possibly some of its new destroyers at the Lombrum base on a rotational basis to support patrols in Southeast Asia, and will probably operate surveillance flights over sea-lanes using drones.

China donated buses and coaches for the upcoming summit, upgraded some major roads and paid for the refitting of Port Moresby’s convention centre but has denied there is any contest with Australia to buy PNG’s allegiance.

“We never interfere in other countries’ domestic affairs and our assistance never comes with political conditions,” foreign minister Wang Yi said during a visit to Port Moresby last weekend.

“To some people, I would say this: rather than pointing fingers at other’s contributions it is better to take the efforts to do more things that will benefit the Pacific island states.”

Papua New Guinea foreign minister Rimbink Pato praised the “remarkable generosity that has sprung out of the hearts of the great Chinese people.”

“We only have to look at the evidence of what is around us how generous China has been to Papua New Guinea as host of APEC,” he said.

Beijing, which is reported to have approached Pacific island state Vanuatu to establish a naval base in the heart of the South Pacific, showed restraint in its response to the Lombrum deal but urged Australia and PNG to discard their “cold war” thinking.

“I think the Pacific island countries should not be the sphere of influence of any country,” foreign ministry spokesman Lu Kang said.

“We hope the relevant countries and relevant people can view China’s relations with Pacific island countries in an objective manner and contribute more to help the countries, rather than making all kinds of speculations.”


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)