The year of APEC – reflections on PNG in 2018
Australians in glass houses are throwing stones at PNG

Manus Island 'smeared' by refugee detention

Michael Kuweh
Michael Kuweh - "Manusians are on the defensive. We have been smeared beyond all description"


AUCKLAND - The reputation of Papua New Guinea's Manus Island has been smeared and its people need to be compensated, says church leader Michael Kuweh.

Mr Kuweh is a layman and spokesperson for the Catholic Diocese of Manus.

The indefinite detention of refugees for nearly six years on the island has brought it into disrepute, he said.

"This is a place that has been tarnished because the Australian government dumped its responsibilities on the island and it has affected nearly 70,000 people on Manus.

"It's not the fault of the refugees, it is the fault of the Australian government who decided to follow a 'Pacific Solution'."

The foisting of hundreds of young, male refugees on the island has led to incidents of hostility and violent conflict with locals.

About 40 children have been born to refugees and local women some of whom have reportedly turned to prostitution.

"They say 'Manus is like hell... Manus is not a place to live because it is very dangerous.' This was never part of our culture or image that was promoted, only when the refugees came around," Mr Kuweh said.

"Manusians are on the defensive," he said. "We are being labelled as a place that no one should visit. We have been smeared beyond all description."

About 600 men remain in detention on the island in three transit centres near Lorengau town. Seven Manus refugees have died since 2014 through murder, medical neglect and suicide.

Suicide attempts and self-harm have escalated since the men were forcibly transferred about 30 kilometres from the prison camp at Lombrum in November 2017.

In September that year, the Australian government paid about 1300 Manus detainees $AU70 million in compensation for suffering in conditions branded inhumane and torturous by a UN special rapporteur.

Mr Kuweh said Australia now needed to make amends with the people of Manus, who wanted the detention project "out".

"The Manus people are no longer good in the eyes of the world because the island has been branded 'not a good place to be'," he said.

"The Australian government owes us a gift package."

"And in part of that, they must come to help restore the image of the province."

While development on the mainland had been funded through the deal PNG struck with Australia to detain the refugees, the layman said the island only got "spinach".

Some of its roads had been resurfaced, some schools had been improved and a market and a police station had been built but that was not enough, Mr Kuweh said.

"The gift package for compensation should look around five or six billion kina ($US1.5 billion)," he said. "It could be more."

Mr Kuweh said Manus Island had a long and unsuccessful history of accommodating refugees and people displaced by conflict.

During World War II about 5000 Manusians were forced off their land when America captured the island from Japan and built military bases, Mr Kuweh said.

Then in 1968 when PNG was an Australian colony, refugees from West Papua fleeing Indonesian occupation were settled on Manus in a camp near Lorengau.

Some of their descendants are still there.

"It has been a burden on us for a long time," Mr Kuweh said. "We would prefer this refugee thing goes. We have our hands full."

Climate change was likely to create more refugees as "80 percent of Manus people are coastal inhabitants and islanders," he said.

But the planned resurrection of the naval base on Manus Island could add to the island's unfortunate legacy of displacement.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Philip Kai Morre

Manusians has been given a problem which is not their doing and I sympathise with what my brother Michael has written.

Manus is naturally a beautiful island with peaceful people and a low crime rate but now it seems to have become worse under the influence with refugees.

Please leave Manus alone, including the proposed naval base, otherwise we will see more problems without solutions.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)