‘We’ll deal to you’ - Namah threatens PNG daily newspapers
My Tolai way of life

PNG faces a climactic moment – will it be another false dawn?

Sir-Peter-Ipatas (Bryan Kramer)
Sir Peter Ipatas speaks at Friday's shock media conference in Port Moresby (Bryan Kramer)


NOOSA – Political turmoil is not unknown in Papua New Guinea but it's the only story occupying people's attention this weekend.

In the wake of the exit of many of his high profile political cronies, and with more MPs likely to follow, can prime minister Peter O’Neill hang on to his leadership?

With a parliamentary vote of no confidence to be brought on in a little over a week from now, PNG’s eight million people won’t be kept in suspense much longer.

And as for O’Neill, in an audio statement released from Beijing Friday evening he reassured supporters that his coalition still had plenty of numbers in parliament and was well able to continue as a stable government.

Earlier, at a dramatic media conference in parliament house in Port Moresby late Friday morning, broadcast live throughout PNG, six of O’Neill’s closest supporters in the ruling People’s National Congress dropped a bombshell.

They collectively announced their resignation from the party setting up a showdown when parliament sits. In quitting, they followed the footsteps of onetime O’Neill confidante and PNG finance minister James Marape, who had walked a fortnight before hurling a long laundry list of complaints at his former colleague.

Each of the leaders, sitting in a row facing a huge media contingent, delivered a homily on why they were exiting and all grasped the money quote from William Powi that “this is a private sacrifice for public good.”

Given previous political experience in PNG, that virtuous rhetoric has yet to be observed in practise.

Behind a string of tables covered by what looked like a bed sheet and many corded microphones were Enga governor Sir Peter Ipatas, Southern Highlands governor William Powi, Hela governor Philip Undialu, Jiwaka governor Dr William Tongap, former attorney-general and Esa’ala (Milne Bay) MP Steven Davis, and vice-minister for petroleum and energy and Komo-Magarima (Hela) MP Manase Makiba.

James Marape was absent and this was noticed, with Undialu explicitly challenging him to follow their example and join the group. More on this later

It was interesting, though, to listen to each of these influential figures offer their rationale on why they were deserting O’Neill at this time.

In these explanations, corruption loomed large. It would be wrong to write that none of these leaders has ever benefited from corruption, but it seems that its great scale under the O’Neill government – of which they have been such a prominent part for many years - has proven too much even for them.

Corruption was specifically mentioned in remarks by Ipatas, Undialu, Davis and Makiba as were the related issues of law and order and institutional decline.

Another key issue was what the leaders saw as a failure by O’Neill to effectively share power - and equitably share the benefits from major mining projects. Landowners in particular have been dudded - but so have the people of  PNG more generally. Greedy politiciand and resource companies .

The extremely high level of overseas loans, public service salaries and service delivery were also mentioned as troubling matters for these senior national figures.

Enga governor Ipatas, who along with Marape and Sam Basil must be looked upon as a possible successor to O’Neill, said that the two outstanding issues for him were the lack of consultation and consensus in the delivery of services and corruption in the government, which he said had reached unprecedented levels in recent years under People’s National Congress rule.

Southern Highlands governor Powi – a provincial colleague of O’Neill – said a fundamental issue of national importance was the continuous failure of the prime minister to strengthen provincial and local level governance and empower the people.

He said the PNG constitution made it clear that elected leaders have a moral obligation to the people they represent and this has been greatly undermined by the current political and administrative structure in PNG.

Hela governor Undialu said bluntly that his own resignation was the result of the government failing to honour its commitments under the PNG LNG project. It has not delivered the promised royalties, grants and other funds under a whole range of agreements.

“I cannot be continue to be like a fool in front of my people who are yet to see real and tangible benefits in terms of promised project, funds and others,” he said.

"Hela is the host province of the over K40 billion first LNG project but there are many unanswered questions that continue to haunt this government.”

Undialu pointed out that, since the first shipment of gas five years ago, over K70 billion had been earned but the O’Neill government was not telling the country where the money was parked and why.

“Where is all the money earned from the PNG LNG project and revenue from forestry, fisheries and other exports?” he asked.

“I’m very frustrated that the prime minister has gone away to China yet again to borrow money, placing a huge burden on our people - this and future generations who will repay the debt.

“Why do we have to still continue to borrow, when we are so blessed with abundant natural resources? Why have we not learnt from the first PNG project?” All good questions.

Former attorney-general Davis blamed the current leadership of failing to put in place anti-corruption measures or to promote and strengthen the rule of law.

Makiba said he resigned from People’s National Congress because, as vice-minister for petroleum and energy, he clearly witnessed breaches in the recent signing of the Papua LNG agreement.

“Three day before signing I opposed it because certain procedures were not complied with. My view is that, in such important investments, members of parliament together with provincial and local level government leaders must be given the opportunity to have their views [considered].

"In this case it was rushed and there are still many outstanding issues that need to be put right,” Makiba said.

Meanwhile, stress fractures are continuing to grow in the Pangu Pati, from which its high profile leader, current finance minister Sam Basil, was expelled after he took the party from opposition into government in 2017.

Basil is registering a new party but the Pangu executive is urging other Pangu MPs not to join him.

If O’Neill and People’s National Congress are ejected from power in the next few weeks, Basil and Marape will undoubtedly be seeking to replace him. And perhaps deputy prime minister Charles Abel will see an opportunity to emerge as a compromise candidate.

But, as Radio New Zealand journalist Johnny Blades says: “Peter O'Neill has been the dominant political player in PNG politics for seven or eight years now. He's a master at garnering the numbers, and we can't count him out just yet.”

We can't and shouldn't, but the count is on.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

A Fairsay

Franzalbert Joku from Sentani, Papua Indonesia, died in Jayapura aged 66 on 28 April. He was married with a daughter and two grandkids.

At aged 17 in 1967 Franz entered PNG as a refugee from Papua because of the fighting between OPM and the Indonesian military.

He went to Rabaul International School and studied professional journalism at Stanford University, USA. His political view was ‘liberty, justice and prosperity for all mankind’.

In December 2018 he was awarded the Companion of the Star of Melanesia (CSM) for his contribution to PNG print media, public policy development of the early government of PNG and promotion of a peaceful relationship between Papua & Indonesia.
(Em TV on Youtube : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Heh8Lr9X37U )

Franz worked for the Post Courier from 1975 to 1992, that's 17 years. He then worked as a secretary in the Prime Minister's Department before becoming Chief of Staff.

He worked for two Deputy PMs and three Cabinet Ministers. He was also Chief of Staff for the PNG Opposition Leader.

In 2007 the Governor of Papua on a visit to PNG asked the people of Papua to return home which Franz decided to do.

Franz and Nick Messet were senior campaigners for the OPM but, after returning to Indonesia, they both began working as advisors to the Politics and Security Ministry.

Franz may have concluded that an armed struggle for Independence would be very costly in human lives and bring misery, and most likely not succeed.

Instead Franz wanted Indonesian laws passed to protect Papuan land and custom rights to give political, social and economic empowerment as indigenous people of their region.

Franz said concerns about human rights issues in Papua expressed in Pacific Islands regional forums were welcome but the Melanesian Spearhead Group, (MSG) and the Pacific Islands Forum should not speak for Papua as its leaders could do that on their own.

A greater share of local resource extraction projects is a positive outcome of Franz's advocacy.

Mr Widodo is in the process of divesting 51 percent of Freeport gold and copper mine its shares in Papua to Indonesian entities.

Papua will get 10 percent, seven percent goes to Mimika Regency where Freeport's Grasberg mine is located, three percent goes to the provincial government.

This deal offered to resource owners is one of the best in the Pacific countries.

Franzalbert Joku has made a contribution to PNG development and in Papua, the land of his home and people, he has made a impact and mark in its future development. RIP.


(from indonesian Wikipedia)

Lindsay F Bond

Tweet by Johnny Blades @JGBlades: “Franz Albert Joku, a West Papuan leader who controversially advocated autonomy for Papua within Indonesia rather than independence, has died aged 66 in hospital in Jayapura.”

Whither options for governance of PNG where, it seems, a prevalence of indifference of folk, rural and remote?


Aha! Hasn't this lot been in team O'Neill from day one?

Didn't they change the law of PNG and bring in new legislation to defraud the people of PNG?

Didn't they enjoy cash bonus as a token of appreciation and support for team O'Neill.

Didn't they help ruin this country by sharing the loan money got on behalf of the country?

Their move now is self-serving and not for the country.

Philip Fitzpatrick

My thoughts entirely Chris.

There is no such thing as a government in PNG, democratic or otherwise. Neither is there an alternative government or opposition. There are just factions of the same mass jockeying to either conserve their place at the trough or step up to take their place.

The recycling of politicians is a real art in PNG. One week they are deadly enemies of the prime minister and the next week they are in bed with him.

You can count the number of real politicians with a concern for their people on one hand.

This little lot has sniffed the possibility of blood in the wind and are positioning themselves to take advantage of it.

They are all hypocrites of the worst kind.

Chris Overland

It takes an heroic level of optimism to believe that O'Neill will be brought down or, in the event that he is, anything really changes for the better.

The people referred to in Keith's article have been an integral part of the O'Neill regime for virtually its entire existence.

They have, whether actively or passively, played a major role in further entrenching corruption and incompetence within PNG.

Why should anyone now believe that they offer any solutions to these problems?

I am deeply sceptical of politicians, in PNG or anywhere else, suddenly recanting from their previous behaviour and indulging in blatant virtue signalling.

This just looks like a falling out between mob bosses to me, because the current Boss of Bosses has reneged on the distribution of the profits of their business activities.

Faith in our democratic institutions has been gravely damaged because our politicians have, to varying degrees, failed to govern in the national interest, preferring instead to govern for the interest groups that fund them or those who can shout the loudest.

Little wonder that, in an era when a serial liar and fraud can be President of the United States, many people now believe that the correct position for any voter about all politicians is one of undisguised cynicism and contempt.

Sadly, in PNG, voters have very many reasons for making the same assumptions.

Papua New Guineans can start to believe that something can change for the better when a new PNG government brings into law the establishment of a well funded, powerful and extremely active ICAC to root out and smash corruption in PNG in all its forms.

Until then, they can assume that the statements attributed to those now abandoning O'Neill are maus wara tasol.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)