Coronavirus: What our correspondents say
Hey Rio! Get back & fix your mess

Spin, prayer & missed opportunities

Indonesia-PNG border at Vanimo


TUMBY BAY - Apart from yesterday’s proposal by East Sepik governor Allan Bird to shoot border crossers from Indonesia, the most astonishing recent Papua New Guinea government statement came from prime minister James Marape on Monday 31 March.

If the report by Glenda Popot of FM100 is accurate, the Covid-19 crisis has prompted the prime minister to admit that “the country’s health system lacks proper resources and care facilities including basic medical drugs”.

Ms Popot reported Marape as saying that the Covid-19 pandemic had “awakened the government to this reality and to make correct interventions to the country’s health system”.

Marape added that the government “will ensure PNG’s health care system after the Covid-19 pandemic is responsive not only to big outbreaks such as this but the everyday health care of Papua New Guineans in all provinces”.

It makes you wonder where James Marape and the members of his government have been for the last 30 or 40 years.

Didn’t they notice the furore over the Borneo Pharmaceuticals scam or the Port Moresby General Hospital sending out requests for people to donate basic medical supplies like bandages which the government had failed to provide?

Didn’t they notice the desperate pleas from hospitals for equipment to treat people with cancer and other diseases and to perform simple procedures like scans and x-rays?

Perhaps they were all in Singapore getting top notch medical treatment at expensive private hospitals paid for by funds ripped off from taxpayers and aid agencies.

PNG is an extreme case of a government callously ignoring the well-being of citizens, but similar realisations are also taking place in developed countries.

In Australia, as Labor shadow treasurer Jim Chalmers observed in The Guardian, “hollowing out the state hurts people. We’re seeing the cold hard consequences of years of cuts and closures dressed-up as ‘savings’ and the outsourcing and offshoring of services in the name of ‘efficiency’.”

Nowhere has this fact become more apparent than in the USA where the Covid-19 crisis is having a devastating impact.

And yet there are still people in the States with their heads buried firmly in the sand, not least their morally bereft and wilfully ignorant president, Donald Trump.

Many world leaders are reluctantly acknowledging, if not in words then in actions, that neoliberalism has been shown to be a miserable failure. All it has achieved is massive inequality-making rich people richer and poor people poorer.

Chalmers went on to say that “every facet of Australian life will be tested by this moment. The quality of our health system, the foundations of our economy, the strength of our democracy and the ties that bind us together are being challenged in ways we could not have imagined weeks ago”.

And yet we have leaders like Trump talking about getting back to business as usual once the crisis has passed.

Australia will find itself in massive debt when it is over. That debt is going to take generations to pay off. But at least our prime minister eventually threw caution to the wind and accepted that people’s lives mattered more than debt.

But where on earth is James Marape going to find the money to bring Papua New Guinea’s health system up to even a basic level of resourcing and efficiency? He is struggling to find the resources to tackle the current crisis let alone what happens after it.

Creating a healthy society involves a lot more than just upgrading a few hospitals. Basic stuff like access to clean water will have to be addressed. So too will housing and sewerage, especially in the towns and cities.

It is a monumental task.

Will it involve more loans, more aid, more grants and more Chinese influence? Is that even possible in a country hocked to the gills already?

And what about all the other sectors of governance that have been neglected? These things all have a knock on effect.

Surely if Marape is going to fix the health system he will need to fix other services, including the education system.

Acknowledging the problem is a good first step but it is going to take more than spin and prayers to genuinely address the task.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Arthur Williams

Why Australia has to bail out PNG is beyond my understanding. Why?

Because we have several world class mines and some smaller that have been in operation for many years.

The loggers have been allowed by either corrupt or stupid. Forestry officials ignoring the parameters of sustainable forest working plans submitted by the rapacious timber companies to achieve permits to log.

PNG should have benefited from the millions of tonnes of tuna fished from its massive sized ocean economic zone.

Oil palmers have steadily expanded their mono-cultural plantations for forty years from the early days of CDC.
There must have been billions earned from the export of the basic crops: copra, coffee, cocoa, rubber, tea.

Someone far far cleverer than me should put together the statistics for all these billions of exports that have flowed from PNG since independence.

I believe we would all be astounded at what has left PNG shores in those 44 years.

Divide the final total by the small population of PNG and it exposes that something evil has happened to prevent PNG being a model nation.

On here experts and others have tried to defend the benefits and morals of the multinationals that to me surely must have knowingly taken advantage of PNG’s poor governance.

Their unrequited greed is not unique to PNG but is happening all over the ‘3rd World’, ‘Undeveloped World’ or ‘Less Developed World’ or whatever fancy title economists may give the sad nations of Africa.

I get fed up of reading about such and such a nation in Africa being among the poorest in the world and only to read elsewhere of mining giants extracting billions from their land or logging giants clear-felling in almost uncontrolled manner over millions of hectares.

Nobody, no government can stop destructive habits of the current era. Perhaps the current virus will slow it but only temporarily. It will not be long before it will be business as usual.

It is gobble-isation not globalisation.

Ian Ritchie

Accordingto AFR,

PM Marape is already talking to Morrison about an AUD3 billion bail out in conjuction with the IMF.

Bernard Corden

A traditional aphorism from the British cosmologist Martin Rees is worth reiterating:

"Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"

Bernard Corden

"An educated, healthy and confident nation is harder to govern" - Tony Benn

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)