Till Death Do Us Part
Can coronavirus bring positive change?

Australian Pacific TV initiative lashed

CaptureKATE LYONS | Pacific Editor
| Guardian Australia | Judith Neilson Institute

SYDNEY - A move to broadcast Australian commercial television, including Neighbours, Border Security and Masterchef in Pacific nations could be counterproductive in promoting Australia’s relationship with the region, an expert media group has warned.

The new PacificAus TV program will allow Australian content to be aired free of charge by broadcasters in seven Pacific nations, at a cost of $17.1m, in a move seen as an attempt to combat Chinese influence in the Pacific region.

Thousands of hours of lifestyle, news, drama and sport will be played on local free-to-air TV networks in Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands and Fiji and the initiative will be expanded to Vanuatu, Kiribati, Tuvalu and Nauru over the coming months.

Announcing the initiative on Monday, Australia’s foreign minister, Marise Payne, said: “Having the opportunity to watch the same stories on our screens will only deepen the connection with our Pacific family.”

The communications minister, Paul Fletcher, said it was a chance for local productions to grab a bigger audience.

“Our close neighbours across the Pacific can now enjoy more Australian television content,” he said.

Jemima Garrett, co-convenor of the Australia Asia Pacific Media Initiative and former Pacific correspondent for the ABC, said the initiative was a welcome recognition that Australia should have a broadcasting voice in the Pacific, but it needed additional programs to be fit for purpose.

“Australia needs to talk ‘with’ not ‘to’ our region and include the rich diversity of Australian voices and voices from the region,” Garrett said.

“Watching rich, white people renovate their homes will not ‘deepen the connection’ with the Pacific or overcome perceptions that Australia can be paternalistic. Nor will providing Border Security in a region in which visa access is a sore point.”

Garrett said that to be effective, Australian broadcasting in the Pacific region should provide content that directly addressed the needs of the region.

“If the PacificAus TV initiative is about building relationships, then co-productions made by Australian and Pacific media companies working together are the way to go,” Garrett said.

“If Australia wants to distinguish its approach from that of expanding Chinese state-owned broadcasters it needs to engage with the region in real partnerships.”

The announcement has been welcomed by some broadcasters across the Pacific, but also received criticism from some journalists and Pacific analysts.

Shailendra Singh, head of the journalism program at the University of South Pacific in Fiji, said the reaction to the news in Fiji had been “lukewarm”.

“Money certainly would have been put to better use developing local content,” he said. “Even if the strategy meets Australia’s geopolitical needs, does it meet the needs of Pacific Islanders? Is Australia putting its needs ahead of the Pacific? These are some of the questions that people are asking.”

Dan McGarry, the former media director at the Vanuatu Daily Post newspaper, wrote that the announcement seemed “silly, seen from here”.

“Pacific islanders want news, they want weather updates, especially during cyclone season. But language and cultural differences make shows like Neighbours irrelevant to most islanders. Entertainment wasn’t what we asked for (except for The Voice – everyone loves that).”

China has increased its diplomatic presence in the Pacific in recent years, leading to two countries – Kiribati and Solomon Islands – switching diplomatic allegiance from Taiwan to China last year.

Last year China’s state-owned broadcaster took over the frequencies left idle when ABC’s Radio Australia ceased shortwave transmission in the region in 2017.

In 2014 the Coalition government closed the Australia Network, the ABC’s international service, which had broadcast TV to 46 countries in Asia and the Pacific.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Philip Fitzpatrick

Listen to Jemima Garrett talking to Jonathan Green on ABC radio here:


She particularly highlights the irony of Australia broadcasting commercial pap like 'Borderforce' into the Pacific given its highly restrictive visa system compared to the easy access Pacific nations give to Australians travelling the other way.

Peter Sandery

Years ago Radio Australia did this extremely well as I remember seeing many of their calendars for example in some pretty remote places. Then the Canberra and Southbank powers that be decreed that it was not a core activity and it was axed. This, combined with the disgraceful neglect of the local radio stations throughout PNG over the last thirty years, as alluded to by KJ, has not served the people of PNG or Australia very well.

Philip Fitzpatrick

It would be interesting to know what people in PNG watch and also what sort of programs they would like to watch.

I don't know that anyone has done any work on this topic.

It is apparent that by watching local television like EMTV how popular locally based stories appeal.

I personally find the crap that Australia broadcasts into the Pacific region embarrassing and often wonder whether Pacific people form their opinions of us from that crap.

My preference would be for ABC/SBS to do the broadcasting but realise that our current government hates both stations because they have a tendency to report the truth.

Maybe some readers could give us a clue about what is required.

Adam Charles Elliott

If past experience is anything to go by the broadcast products will be pretty weak and lack any kind of consistent identity or editorial voice.

And whatever I think as an Australian and what might be OK to broadcast in Australia might not be so well received in the Pacific.

As the article notes it might be entertaining but it might not be useful.

I guess it will tick-a-box in Australia's Pacific step-up.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)