Inside the mind of the Melanesian poet
Heroes of modern PNG literature

The chasm in cultural integrity

Kj
Keith Jackson - "The apparent demise of the Crocodile Prize reflects dismally on the government’s commitment to the cultural and social force of home-grown literature; a force that can be such a critical component of nation-building and social strengthening"

KEITH JACKSON

NOOSA - Successive national and foreign governments and organisations have directed development aid to a range of programs in Papua New Guinea – some successful, too many not.

But in doing so they have overlooked a huge cultural influence that not only represents the beating heart and animated spirit of the nation but is also a bearer of learning, personal understanding and social cohesion.

The marvel to which I refer is a hardy creation that refuses to die even when denied nurture, encouragement and recognition.

It is a home-grown literature that will amplify the creativity, culture and spirit of Papua New Guineans.

But, lacking the required support, literature has not emerged in PNG as an influence capable of playing its vital role in education, in nation building or in people’s lives.

This marvel - the written word in all its forms - which, says Dr Anthony Olaoye of the University of Abuja in Nigeria, “opens people’s eyes to a wide range of experiences and a deeper understanding of these experiences [as] an authentic mirror image of its society and time.”

After nearly 10 years of seeking to revive a Papua New Guinean written literary tradition which emerged with substance only in the 1960s, here in 2020 my co-conspirator Phil Fitzpatrick and I remain bemused by the lack of insight and enthusiasm for a home-grown literature among the politicians and bureaucrats of Papua New Guinea.

This failing is also seen in most of the patron agencies and organisations contributing to PNG's progress, which habitually assure us they want to see the nation grow and develop in the interests of its people.

So the development of a national literature in Papua New Guinea continues to be overlooked, ignored or considered of little importance. And thus it is failing to emerge as the influential force it could be in education, nation building and social cohesion.

That literature does survive in the hearts and minds of many people despite the neglect, however, is a powerful sign revealing a powerful creative spirit awaiting the means to be enabled full expression, as Phil and I found soon after conceiving the Crocodile Prize national literary awards in 2010.

In a climate constrained by an acute shortage of the resources a successful enterprise requires, the Crocodile Prize managed to string out a living, including establishing related projects in publishing, mentoring and tours and networking both in PNG and overseas.

But it has always been hampered by its smallness, impoverishment and lack of organisation.

There have been white knights that have helped, however the necessary strength and scope could not occur in the absence of support from established institutions which could provide a home-grown literature with a permanent and sustainable presence.

That said, under the auspices of a small voluntary group, seven national literary contests have been held, six anthologies of the best writing from those contests have been published, and 50 books mostly by Papua New Guinean authors have been produced.

These have sold poorly – cost and distribution being deadly obstacles.

And, perhaps more important, the Crocodile Prize foundered in 2017 and attempts to revive it have not succeeded.

In desperation, in 2019, a group of Papua New Guinean writers composed a manifesto seeking to establish meaningful, tangible and sustained government and institutional support for PNG literature.

It was submitted to Papua New Guinea's prime minister, James Marape, but a promised meeting with him has been postponed twice and, to date there is no indication whether it will be held at all.

It reflects dismally on the commitment at an official level to an important cultural force that can be a critical component of nation-building and social strengthening, especially in a developing country.

The Crocodile Prize was both an organising principle and a source of motivation and in many cases, without it, the creative impulse has been blunted.

That said, however, hundreds of writers continue to write and PNG Attitude continues to publish their writing.

But without official Papua New Guinean encouragement, and a whole-hearted commitment to a home-grown literature, a gaping hole in Papua New Guinea’s cultural integrity may re-emerge 10 years after a renaissance was experienced after a long gap that dated back to the literary outpouring that surrounded the years around national independence in 1975.

______________

The 2019 Manifesto for Literature in Papua New Guinea

We, the writers of Papua New Guinea, believe that our nation’s literature is something that needs to be encouraged and supported by everyone, but especially by the government.

Without a home-grown literature the story of our great nation cannot be told.

If our story is not told, future generations of Papua New Guineans will not be fully aware of where they come from, who they are and what made them.

A nation without a story is like a nation without a soul.

The writers of Papua New Guinea are currently struggling to tell our nation’s story.

There are no major publishers in Papua New Guinea interested in publishing our work. If we want to publish our books, we have to pay for it ourselves.

Our books are not available in schools. The students of Papua New Guinea cannot read books written by their own countrymen and women.

Instead, they have to read books written by writers from other countries.

Papua New Guinea has a poorly resourced public library system. Few of our own books are available in these libraries. In most cases Papua New Guinean authors have to donate books free of charge to libraries so people can read them.

Our national literary award, the Crocodile Prize, is struggling to survive. It is supported by limited private funding. The Papua New Guinean government has never shown real interest in supporting it. Nor has the government shown an interest in supporting Papua New Guinean writers.

It is time this situation changed.

We, the undersigned writers of Papua New Guinea, together with our readers and supporters, are calling upon our new Prime Minister, James Marape, to commit his government and future governments to providing the support our writers, our literature and our nation deserve.

It is time to secure the story of Papua New Guinea for present and future generations.

To do less is unthinkable

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Bernard Corden

Here are some additional interesting links:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Two_Cultures

https://s3-eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/renewolf-wp-data/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/2010_11_04_OnoraONeill_lecture.mp3

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/winston-churchill-on-the-arts/

Lindsay F Bond

As flew with Tinkerbell, Phil? Too small a tot beyond 'what'? To "read and appreciate" requires imagination, and uplift.

To a few may be known the name J M Barrie, whence came 'Tinkerbell'.

Is it too much a metaphor to envisage a tot as of 'writing that flies'?

"Throughout his life Barrie wished to recapture the [his] happy years."

See: https://www.britannica.com/biography/J-M-Barrie

Yet a man of writing "whimsicalities" became chancellor of the University of Edinburgh in 1930.

Thus from the strictures of Scotland oozed essence of impart, words as on the wing.

Strangely of this author came a character unhindered by adulthood and "Peter [Pan] was in fact intended to be the true villain of the story."

Philip Fitzpatrick

Once upon a time in a land far away students went to university to get a 'rounded' education.

Even students who were studying specialised courses like medicine and engineering were required to study subjects in what was known as the 'humanities'. This included literature. In some universities humanitities subjects were a compulsory part of any degree.

In that distant land the powers that be recognised that learning to read and appreciate literature and philosophy made for a better human being.

Nowadays, in that distant land, students go to study to get a good job with high wages. Being a good human being isn't seen as a part of those professions they hope to join.

Without that basic grounding that mystical land has now become dominated by greedy corporations and money hungry employees and the universities have become part of that mix.

Some of us old buggers who once lived in that magical place can remember when life had a different meaning.

Michael Dom

I'm convinced that reading and writing are incorrectly viewed as mere hobbies to our own detriment.

How do we think critically without reading and writing?

(This also includes the creative activities of art, music and dance.)

The single most important benefit that the Marape government could provide to nurturing the soul of present and future Papua New Guineans is a literary awards organisation that promotes writers, provides our own books, captures and reflects our unique cultures, stories and perspectives, and thereby acts as a catalyst for young children to read from and not just about their own nation.

In the Crocodile Prize, the Marape government has a unique opportunity to create a fertile garden for our nation to be truthfully rooted and nourished.

Wanem kaikai yumi planim, em tasol bai yumi kaikai.

Philip Fitzpatrick

One of the most stunning and ubelieveable events in this sorry saga occurred when the PNG Prime Minister, James Marape, decided that it was more important to play golf than meet with the writer's representatives waiting in his office (for a second time) to present him with a copy of the petition.

It was it that point that I realised that the new prime minister, despite all of the positive rhetoric he had expounded in the preceding months, was just another empty vessel just like all of the prime ministers before him.

All he had to do was forgo a silly game and sit down for twenty minutes to listen to PNG's writers but he couldn't be bothered.

As the boss of Exxon Mobil once observed of Donald Trump, another feckless leader, "what a fucking moron!"

Lindsay F Bond

Perhaps PNG national ‘infancy’ is prolonged by babes who hold to babel? Is it that historical multiplicity of languages has vantage for they who babble? Of situations that are oral and aural and allowed, is it that some folk who stymie on literature are likely those whose grasp is loud yet tenuous?

Passionately pleading of
poets reaching readers mist in digital cloud
pondering if 'pollies' loft
poses dressing dancers mixed in actual crowd
poised by promises oft
promenading propensity none missed by loud
pert latter way taints soft
putting prospect leadings, shrugged, as covert in shroud.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)