Why neo-liberals can’t handle a crisis
A Kiap’s Chronicle: 28 – In defence of the people’s land

Racism diminished but not dead

B&w Overland hline
Chris Overland - "Entrenched ideas about the world die very hard"


ADELAIDE - Racism originates from one of the most deep seated aspects of all human cultures, which is an almost instinctive ‘fear of the other’.

I have written previously (see my comment on this article) about this phenomenon and why it made sense in the distant past and, in relation to Papua New Guinea, the not so recent past.

This aspect of human cultures is not restricted to white Caucasians. There are innumerable examples from other cultures as well, many of which persist today.

There is not a shred of scientific evidence that a person’s skin colour has any material bearing upon their intellect or character.

DNA studies reveal that skin colour is amongst the most trivial of variations in human beings, being simply an adaption to differing climatic conditions.

The persistence of racist beliefs reflects the unpleasant fact that a large number of human beings are insensitive, ignorant and rather stupid about this specific issue and many others besides.

This helps explain why Adolph Hitler and his criminal cronies could win 44% of the vote in the 1932 elections in Germany, with the population then doggedly following their Fuhrer to catastrophe even when the true nature of Nazism was evident.

In a similar way, a distressingly large minority of Americans feel so threatened by their coloured fellow citizens that they will throw their support behind a narcissistic sociopath who is devoid of insight, empathy or much in the way of intelligence.

Racism is what might be called a “wicked problem”, in that there seem to be no immediately effective ways to counteract it beyond endlessly repeating that it has no basis in fact and invariably leads to great injustice and suffering.

Some academics believe that the incidence of what might be called ‘pure’ racism has diminished markedly, at least in the democratic world.

The recent enormous popular support across the world for the Black Lives Matter movement is fairly clear evidence that this is indeed the case.

On that basis, it is reasonable to conclude that we probably now have an irreducible minimum number of hard core racists in our midst.

In Australia, I would suggest that the proportion of the population who fit this category is no larger than around 5%.

I say this because as long ago as 1967 some 91% of eligible voters cast their votes in favour of removing blatantly discriminatory laws that reduced Aboriginal people to the status of non-citizens.

Unhappily, a much larger proportion of the population is in the category I mentioned earlier, being insensitive, ignorant and stupid.

They can be easily deluded into supporting actions and behaviours that are racist in nature without even comprehending that this is the case.

For example, the persistent large scale abuse of Aboriginal footballer Adam Goode in the latter stage of his career was carried out by people who, when asked, declared that they were not being racist but merely expressing disapproval of how he played the game.

Only later did it dawn upon some of these people that their actions were being understood by Aboriginal people as racist even if they didn’t share that understanding.

I agree with Michael Dom that the starting point for eradicating these baseless and harmful ideas lies in personal insight followed by moral action.

As I am sure Michael knows, this is much harder to achieve in practice than in theory. Entrenched ideas about the world die very, very hard indeed.

This being the case, our political class must resign themselves to the very long term task of, firstly, suppressing racist behaviour wherever it occurs and, secondly, striving to change attitudes about race. The latter task is much harder than the former.

In the case of policing in the USA, this must include relentlessly training police officers to understand the socio-economic contexts within which they are working, as well as seriously attempting to reduce their apparent reliance upon heavy handed and even lethal force as all too graphically displayed in the case of George Floyd.

The number of deaths in police custody in the USA is twice as high as that in Australia and six times higher than in the UK.

As Phil Fitzpatrick has indicated, there is an underlying issue at work here, being the exploitative and deeply unfair nature of American capitalism.

Until that it dealt with, I suspect that there will be little other worthwhile change to the current situation of non-white people in the USA.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Michael Dom

"The persistence of racist beliefs reflects the unpleasant fact that a large number of human beings are insensitive, ignorant and rather stupid about this specific issue and many others besides" - Chris Overland

Well said.

Republican senator Ted Cruz home town is Houston Texas. On June 4 he gave a long and emphatic speech to end the violence committed in the name of the martyred criminal George Floyd.


In this speech Cruz conflates protest with violence - a Republican talking point but a dubious proposition - KJ

Garry Roche

Personally I believe that there may be elements of racism in many of us. And often we are not aware of that racism as it is may be hidden in many of our presumptions and cultural prejudices.

Back in 1971 I was a young missionary based in Togoba parish in the Nebyler Valley.

There was a government primary school in the parish at a place called Keltiga alongside the then main road from Mt Hagen to Mendi and Wabag.

As parish priest of Togoba I was involved in getting the Catholic students at the school ready for communion and confirmation.

The head teacher there at that time was a Mr Moro Kini, a Papuan. Another teacher was a Bougainville man, Anthony Tsora, and there was also an Australian named Peter Monagle teaching there.

On one occasion after a few sessions of teaching the Catholic students, I was talking to Mr Moro Kini and I said that I was surprised at how intelligent the students were.

Moro Kini politely but clearly reminded me that I should not have presumed otherwise.

I cannot remember his exact words, but it was basically similar to what Chris Overland has put in his blog: “There is not a shred of scientific evidence that a person’s skin colour has any material bearing upon their intellect or character.”

I had to stop and think, and admit to myself that perhaps I had being presuming the students would not have high intelligence.

On another occasion when based in Karap in the Jimi Valley, I made some derogatory remark about an ethnic group in the presence of the kiap at Tabibuga, Jack Edwards, who, to his credit, challenged me on the matter, forcing me to rethink what I had been saying.

Even apparently innocent questions can have a racist interpretation. If here in Ireland, where I am presently, I ask a dark-skinned person, “Where are you from”, that can be interpreted as implying “You are not from here, go home”. I have to be careful how I pose questions.

Perhaps we begin to eliminate racism by first checking for it within ourselves. Our efforts at boosting our own self-confidence may sometimes result in belittling people from other ethnic groups. We may have cultural presumptions that result in attitudes that are racist. But there has been progress.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)