The Anzac myth & our ignored frontier wars
A day to remember that 'war is hell'

Anzac must honour values of peace, not war


TUMBY BAY – For the past month or so, the Returned Services League (RSL) has saturated us with television commercials drumming up interest in today’s Anzac Day celebrations (now cancelled in Perth because of Covid).

That Anzac Day has been turned into a lucrative money-making industry for many organisations, including the RSL, couldn’t be made any clearer.

The advertisements exhort us to not only honour and commemorate but also donate money. This is particularly telling.

So too is the fact that many veterans of Australia’s recent wars find the RSL irrelevant and do not participate in Anzac Day commemorations. My son, who served in East Timor and Iraq, is one of them.

It is not beyond the realms of possibility that once the now aged veterans of the Vietnam War fade away so too will the RSL.

Anzac Day has, rightly or wrongly, been depicted as glorifying war. As has, in recent times, the Australian War Memorial.

This is a complex argument but it is instructive that one particular group from Australia’s many wars has always been judiciously ignored by the RSL.

This is the cohort of conscientious objectors.

The courage of these people who refused to participate in the military because of their opposition to war has never been acknowledged.

If you don’t think that it takes courage to object to war and refuse to take part in it, read the unflinching account by New Zealander Archibald Baxter (1881-1970) in his book, ‘We Will not Cease’, first published in 1939.

LestweforgetThe book is an epic record of Baxter’s brutal treatment as a conscientious objector during World War I.

In 1915, when he was 33, Baxter was arrested, sent to prison and shipped under guard to Europe, where he was forced to the front line against his will.

He was punished to the limits of all dignity. He was beaten, starved and left for dead naked and strapped to a post outside in the snow.

Baxter survived but, in a final attempt to discredit him, the authorities consigned him to a mental hospital.

You can also read the autobiography of American dissenter, David Dellinger, one of the famous Chicago Eight, ‘From Yale to Jail.

Dellinger (1915-2004), a lifelong anti-war activist, refused to fight in World War II and actively opposed every US war thereafter. He served many spells in prison.

DellingerHis most important role was to organise protests against the Vietnam war during the 1968 Democratic presidential nomination convention in Chicago.

Dellinger was subsequently prosecuted and imprisoned by the US government for (among other things) conspiracy to cross state lines with intent to incite a riot.

Just imagine if there had been more men with the courage of Baxter and Dellinger. Just imagine if men refused to bear arms and fight each other. It’s not an idea as unlikely as it seems.

ABC broadcaster Phillip Adams tells of how, during World War I, there were more than 23,000 courts martial of Australian soldiers resulting from desertion or soldiers going absent without leave. This is not a small number.

Adams sheds light on the many men who resisted war however they could, and reveals the determination of some national leaders to continue World War I despite repeated opportunities to settle for peace.

American president Joe Biden is finally bringing the disastrous and pointless 20 year war in Afghanistan to a close. That war took the lives of 3,502 soldiers, including 41 Australians.

And it led to the deaths of at least 150,000 Afghan civilians. There are no accurate official statistics.

All this for nothing.

This is not something worth glorifying.

PeaceLet’s not forget the people who died but also let’s try, wherever possible, to avoid war where we can and not glorify it when it finishes.

As William de Maria observed, in a piece published yesterday in PNG Attitude: “This once-a-year military version of the Melbourne Cup is now a flag waving carnival of deceit and smugness. A Mardi Gras with guns.”

Let us all become conscientious objectors to this modern rendition of Anzac Day.

Let us make Anzac Day a commemoration of courage and sacrifice, and with an unwavering commitment to peace not war.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Paul Joseph Desailly

While Adams and Fitzpatrick rightly depict (1) the difficulties as to finally bringing war to an end (2) back stories re corporate profits gained in war (3) the mindlessness of belligerent nationalists devoid of true patriotism and (4) the abuse of power by certain political leaders, intent at any cost, on remaining in office, let's remember that Anzac Day has morphed into the sort of World Peace movement that many a Digger longed for.

April 25th in recent decades in Australia and New Zealand provides perhaps the most important occasion for national unity. Honouring sacrifices of the fallen and sorrow at the loss of life in war and in its aftermath for friend and foe alike, moves patriots and pacifists, together with admirers of the ANZAC Peace Prize, to align this public holiday with plebiscites held at the height of World War 1. The Australian people and the troops in the trenches narrowly rejected conscription for military service abroad, twice invoked, in 1916 and 1917, by an Empire-oriented, if not jingoistic, and at Versailles, bombastically racist, Prime Minister Billy Hughes (1862 – 1952). In abrogating holy war, controversially known nowadays as Jihad, the founder of the Baha'i religion (1817 - 1892) nevertheless firmly advocated collective security, an ideal, which as a last resort for a future world parliament, precludes neither military service (not necessarily as an armed combatant!) nor the use of force deployed by battalions of justice.

Philip Fitzpatrick

Ted Ryan was an Australian soldier during WW1 opposed to war. Douglas Newton's book is well-worth reading.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)