Dobasi Wandkii
PNG failing to meet human rights obligations

Oz diplomacy tested as Covid slams PNG

New covid cases
The steep rise in new Covid cases in PNG that has alarmed authorities on both sides of the Torres Strait

| Nikkei Asia

SYDNEY -- Papua New Guinea long appeared to have escaped the worst of the coronavirus crisis. But a surge in cases since February has brought the country’s largest hospital to the brink of collapse.

For the nation's much larger neighbour, Australia, the outbreak is considered a serious threat as well as a critical moment in a broader ‘vaccine diplomacy’ campaign.

"If infections continue at the same rate ... it won't be long before we get down to a level of staffing where it is not possible to continue the health service," said Professor Glen Mola, a senior gynecologist and long-time staff member at Port Moresby General Hospital in Port Moresby.

"It is absolutely mind boggling."

PNG has around 500 doctors for its nine million people, or one for every 17,000.

Coronavirus cases have tripled in a month, bringing the total to 5,349 with 49 deaths, and low testing rates may be hiding the true scale of the outbreak.

Prime Minister James Marape believes a quarter of the population might be infected.

The virus is now engulfing hospital personnel. In a single week, 120 staff members at the General Hospital contracted Covid-19 and were forced into isolation.

After a photograph of a woman dying in the hospital's parking lot circulated on social media, the facility's CEO warned more such deaths were a possibility.

The risks extend beyond PNG's shores: To the south, Queensland has seen record numbers of cases in its hotel quarantine program and has the most active infections anywhere in the country.

The majority of positive cases in hotel quarantine are people who returned from PNG.

While Australia has handled the pandemic well, outbreaks in its hotel quarantine system have highlighted the precarious nature of that success.

In Victoria, quarantine failures were blamed for 768 deaths, more than 18,000 infections and months of hard lockdown in Melbourne last year.

When it comes to Queensland, the state's cultural, geographical and economic connection with PNG means the island's struggle poses a real and present danger.

The Australian government has vowed to help PNG contain the outbreak.

It has sent almost 8,500 vaccine doses to immunize frontline workers in its former colony and is considering distributing more once it begins to ramp up local production of the AstraZeneca shot.

These efforts are just a small part of Australia's vaccine diplomacy in the Pacific.

As a member of the Quad - an informal but increasingly high-profile grouping with US, India and Japan - it has committed $100 million (K270 million) to help distribute one billion vaccines to Asian and Pacific Island nations by the end of 2022.

This is on top of Australia's $523 million (K1.4 billion) Regional Vaccine Access and Health Security Initiative for the Pacific and Southeast Asia.

Even after the crisis on its doorstep is addressed and the pandemic wanes, some analysts expect Australia to play an integral role in helping the Pacific region repair the economic damage and move forward. It is vying for influence with China, which in January expressed a willingness to supply vaccines to Pacific states as well.

The Australian government already has its ‘Pacific Step-up’ initiative, unveiled by former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull in 2016. The policy aims to boost regional engagement in the region and counter Beijing's growing clout.

At the heart of this ‘step-up’ is the Australian Infrastructure Financing Facility for the Pacific, which will bankroll infrastructure through a combination of $1.5 billion (K4 billion) in loans and $500 million (K1.3 billion) in grants.

Operational since 2019, it has already backed three major projects: a solar farm in PNG, a hydropower system in the Solomon Islands and an undersea cable in Palau. Canberra is due to sign off on $300 million (K800 million) in funding for other projects in the coming months.

The Asian Development Bank estimates the Pacific needs $US30 billion (K105 billion) worth of infrastructure investment by 2030. The challenge is identifying projects that are commercially viable, according to Jonathan Pryke, director of the Lowy Institute's Pacific Islands Program.

Many investors are wary of bankrolling projects in small, remote economies. China does not seem to share these concerns.

"But the reality is these projects [backed by China] have now been produced and it turns out they are overpriced and variable quality," Pryke said.

"I think Pacific governments have become much savvier, because they only have so many bites at these projects due to their limited access to debt."

He said that infrastructure has become "a contested space" between China and Australia, and that vaccines are another "geopolitical battleground.

"While welcoming the Quad's vaccine commitment, he said the reality is that the rollout across the Pacific will likely be "messier, much more bilateral, and driven by individual parties."

Either way, island states need vaccines -- and quickly.

"The economic devastation in the Pacific is severe and PNG is a genuine health crisis," Pryke said. "These countries can't afford to wait, their economies are going to be started on the back of travel, and that is not going to happen until there is a significant vaccine rollout."

But like China, Australia could run into skepticism of its foreign policy ambitions.

In the past, Australia has been criticized for only engaging with the Pacific in times of crisis. Australia's action on climate change domestically, or lack of it, is also seen negatively in island countries that are among the most susceptible.

Last year, 14 Pacific leaders condemned Australia's Paris climate target as "one of the weakest" in an open leader to prime minister Scott Morrison.

"There is a fair degree of skepticism in the region that the only reason Australia is showing interest now is because China is showing interest, and if China was to go away, Australia would forget about the region again," said Tess Newton Cain, project leader for the Griffith Asia Institute's Pacific Hub.

Newton Cain believes there is not only an economic opportunity, but a moral imperative, to work with China in supporting Pacific development.

She said Australia should not allow geopolitical concerns "whether they are driven from Canberra or Washington, to get in the way of countries which are dealing with a humanitarian crisis."

Newton Cain suggested further loosening labor mobility laws to boost regional economies. This could expand upon an existing seasonal workers program that allows people from eight Pacific island countries and East Timor to work in parts of Australia facing personnel shortages.

It is a view shared by one of Australia's top banks, ANZ, which also advocates a faster region-wide vaccine rollout and infrastructure support to spur a tourism-led job recovery.

But these are matters for Australia to ponder another day.

Right now, time is running out for PNG. Prof Mola at Port Moresby General Hospital says the country faces huge logistical challenges, when it comes to distributing vaccines and stopping the outbreak. Few reliable roads link Port Moresby with rural corners of the country.

With most of the elderly population living in the latter, the country will be in serious trouble if the outbreak spreads.

Another complication is growing vaccine skepticism -- especially after the opposition leader called for suspending Australian-donated shots over safety concerns.

Mola believes the situation is so dire that Australian Defence Force personnel may have to be deployed to assist Papua New Guinea, as in previous crises. Ultimately, he sees no easy solutions.

"It is difficult to see how it is all going to work, actually," he said. "Pray for us."


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Philip Kai Morre

In this period of Covid-19 we are not only dealing with facts.

False information, fear and conspiracy theories are far worse.

Is it true that Angau Hospital has closed because half the their staff is infected with Covid-19?

How come if such medical workers were alert and followed all the Covid-19 regulations and protocols?

Doctors at Angau walked off the job yesterday expressing concerns about staff shortages and pay. I have no more recent information - KJ

Albert Schram

Only mobility restrictions and vaccines in many arms will help. Meanwhile, Angau hospital in Lae has been closed for days now because about half the staff contracted Covid.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)