Australia & PNG develop a security treaty
Now at last, the return of the legendary Telek

Solomons partnership must be truth-based

Australia claims to be a friend and family to the Pacific, and it is true Australia has been an important aid donor for decades. But gratitude for this aid is tempered by scepticism about who it actually helps

Sogavare Albanese
Prime ministers Sogavare and Albanese - sweet talk of 'family' is no substitute for a genuine and equitable relationship

| Pursuit | The University of Melbourne

MELBOURNE - Last week, Solomon Islands prime minister Manasseh Sogavare and Australia’s Anthony Albanese met in Canberra for the first time, less than a month after Australia offered to fund Solomon Islands’ elections to avoid delay.

Since Solomon Islands signed a security pact with China earlier this year, the country has garnered unprecedented global attention.

In recent diplomatic engagements, international leaders are sensibly downplaying their geostrategic self-interest to speak of common values.

A deep, shared and enduring history was highlighted at both last week’s Canberra meeting and the Declaration on the US-Pacific Partnership.

But few have recognised that this shared history is one in which powerful outsiders, including Australia, have exploited Solomon Islands’ land, labour, and resources for their own benefit.

Indeed, when US deputy secretary of state Wendy Sherman described the Battle of Guadalcanal in 1942 as a collaborative fight to “ensure a free Solomon Islands, a democracy, an independent country,” she omitted the uncomfortable fact that the US military quickly handed the territory back to the British colonial administration that forcefully repressed post-war anti-colonial movements.

On her very first day in office, Australian foreign minister Penny Wong pledged to “build a stronger Pacific family” and “to listen, because we care.”

In the spirit of contributing to this dialogue, we share insights from a conversation hosted by the University of Melbourne that focused on how Solomon Islanders see Australia.

Reflections on our shared history must start with the fact that Solomon Islanders see (white) Australia as a colonised and a colonising place.

European settlers in Australian colonies were active as traders and planters in Solomon Islands. Many gave pittances for valuable resources, including land.

Queensland and New South Wales sugar plantations were built on the sweat, tears, and lives of indentured Pacific labourers until the racist immigration policies of the Australian Federation forced tens of thousands of labourers back to their countries of origin.

Colonial policies aimed at extracting the wealth from the Solomons – and investing little in the well-being of the people – had devastating structural effects, including the deep inequalities that contributed to the civil conflict of 1998 to 2003.

The policies were also intergenerational tragedies.

One author’s family name – Hunhak – remembers an ancestor taken from the island of Malaita to labour in Australia who never returned.

Today, Australia claims to be a friend and family to the Pacific. Australia has been an important aid donor for decades, most evident during the years of the Regional Assistance Mission to Solomon Islands (RAMSI) from 2003 to 2013.

Gratitude for this aid is tempered by scepticism about who it actually helps.

Thousands of Australian consultants pass through the country, living in top-quality housing, driving expensive vehicles and earning salaries higher than they would in Australia as an incentive to work in a ‘difficult’ place like Solomon Islands.

Among the unintended side effects of RAMSI was a skyrocketing of real estate prices that made a few property owners rich but made urban life more difficult for ordinary working people.

Australian aid has focused on challenges of governance, infrastructure, policing and policy development.

Important though these programs are, the benefits may not be as visible to ordinary people as, for example, the new stadium and hospital wing that have been supported by Chinese aid.

One perceived benefit of increased geostrategic competition is that Australia has become more responsive to Solomon Islands government priorities.

Discussions of shared history must recognise that while the People’s Republic of China is a new partner to the Solomon Islands government, Chinese people have engaged with Solomon Islanders since the 1920s.

Ordinary Islanders arguably engage more with Chinese people who have settled long-term in the country than they do with (mostly white) Australians who stay temporarily.

No Australian policy undermines its claim of being a member of the Pacific family more than immigration policy.

An Australian citizen can buy a ticket, arrive in Honiara and get a three-month holiday visa at Customs.

A Solomon Islands citizen cannot so much as transit through Australia without a visa, and the process for getting one is slow, complex and expensive.

It’s hard to overstate how much anger this passport inequality generates.

Moreover, when Australian governments and industries look to the Pacific neighbourhood – they seek unskilled, temporary, horticultural workers.

Thousands of Solomon Islanders have earned much-needed income through the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility scheme, but workers have also suffered mistreatment, wage theft and other forms of exploitation.

They feel precarious. When prime minister Sogavare blasted Australia’s interference earlier this year, they were worried their contracts would be cancelled.

Pacific Islanders have migrated more permanently to regional Australia for decades, but they are often invisible to policymakers and excluded from the benefits of citizenship.

Their working-age children find it difficult to move out of the low-paid, insecure work that drew their parents to Australia.

Solomon Islanders have enormous contributions to make to Australia.

Who better than someone who has grown up speaking several Indigenous languages – Solomon Islands Pijin and English – to teach in multicultural schools or lead diversity initiatives?

What if Australia’s Pacific diplomacy was led by Pacific Islander Australians?

The current Australian government seems genuinely committed to building respectful relations with Pacific neighbours.

It has recognised that climate change is the most important existential threat to the region and the world.

Foreign minister Wong has also flagged a desire to incorporate First Nations Perspectives into international diplomacy.

The government must move beyond vague words about shared history to acknowledge the degree to which their country’s wealth was grounded in part on the exploitation of Pacific labour, land and resources – and that outsiders benefitted more than locals from this history.

Even if the flow of aid moves from Australia to Solomon Islands – and not the reverse – Australians still have much to learn from Solomon Islanders about how to establish a just, equitable and sustainable society.

Honiara and Iron Bottom Sound (Shutterstock)

* Dorothy Wickham is founder and editor of Melanesian News Network and Member of the Media Association of Solomon Islands; Associate Professor Tarcisius Tara Kabutaulaka is at the Centre for Pacific Islands Studies, University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa; Dean Wickham is an adjunct research fellow in Anthropology, Latrobe University and Honorary Consul of Solomon Islands in Victoria; Hunhak Matt Gale is former teaching principal in the Northern Territory and former President of Solomon Islands, Victoria Association; and Dr Debra McDougall is senior lecturer in Anthropology, School of Social and Political Sciences, Faculty of Arts, University of Melbourne


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)