I think it’s good if Tkatchenko won’t resign
15 May 2023
MICHAEL KUBANI
| Academia Nomad
Supplementary information by Keith Jackson
PORT MORESBY – Following his 'primitive animals' abuse of social media critics, demands are growing for Papua New Guinea’s foreign minister Justin Tkatchenko to quit his ministry or even resign from parliament.
Other people are calling for his passport to be revoked and then have him deported.
Tkatchenko, 50, came to PNG from Melbourne, Australia, in the early 1990s.
The young man had some training in horticulture and was employed as curator of the Port Moresby’s Botanical Gardens.
By 1997, he was prominent enough to be awarded the British Empire Medal for services to the orchid industry and tropical gardening. By then, he was also politically active.
He was naturalised as a Papua New Guinean citizen in 2006 and ran unsuccessfully in the 2007 PNG elections, defeated by incumbent MP Dame Carol Kidu.
After Dame Carol's retirement from politics, Tkatchenko won the seat in 2012.
It is not possible to be a member of the PNG parliament as a dual citizen, so it is safe to assume he has only one passport – that of PNG.
Crude and disrespectful though it is, calling someone a ‘primitive animal’ doesn’t qualify as grounds to have his passport revoked.
Tkatchenko is a PNG citizen and has equal rights before the law to seek judicial review to retain his citizenship should it be revoked.
In hindsight, some people are probably wishing Tkatchenko was never given citizenship status.
But I believe it’s a good thing he hasn’t resigned as a member of parliament.
If he resigns, it will be impossible for the Ombudsman Commission to investigate him not only for his unprofessional conduct but also for potential abuse of funds.
By law, the Commission can only investigate people occupying public office, not those who have ceased to hold the office.
If Tkatchenko resigns, he immediately becomes a private citizen, evading the Commission’s ambit.
However, if Tkatchenko does resign, complaints can be made to the police fraud squad which has the power to investigate claims of abuse of funds.
The fraud squad cannot investigate unprofessional conduct, such as calling people ‘primitive animals’, which is not a criminal offence.
The Ombudsman Commission, on the other hand, has the duty of ensuring that leaders and public servants maintain professional and ethical standards.
Because Tkatchenko called Papua New Guineans primitives or animals, the use of these words makes it an ethical issue worth investigating.
It seems that already many Papua New Guineans have submitted complaints to the Ombudsman to investigate Tkatchenko and the entourage which accompanied him to King Charles’ Coronation – including his daughter whose boasting triggered a social media onslaught.
So Tkatchenko would appear to be trapped.
Like most PNG members of parliament, he is prideful and egotistical and not planning to resign.
He’s stepped aside to let things cool down, and the US president’s visit to proceed without steet protests.
Presumably, Tkatchenko’s hoping to return as foreign affairs minister or in some other ministerial capacity when the fuss dies down.
But the longer he remains an MP, the more he risks being investigated by the Ombudsman Commission.
The best outcome for those wanting to hold him to account, therefore, is to hope he doesn’t resign.
And also to hope that his case will not be one of those that the Commission decides to overlook. Surely the sheer numbers of complaints should make it take notice and act.
Science lesson for one or more PNG members of parliament to note how far deep in history the human achievement can be celebrated.
Let's make it an early primary school lesson that the earliest traceable event was 200,000 years ago.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-06/worlds-oldest-known-burial-site-found-in-s-africa/102444736
Easy number to remember, 200,000 years.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 06 June 2023 at 01:01 PM
The local newspapers reported today that the Ombudsman officially confirmed a meeting Tkatchenko.
It was stated to him that, where there is likely to be a conflict of interest, the leader puts the interest of their people before their own (family) interest.
This has to be the easiest case ever for Ombudsman in its history.
Next will be Marape's role in approving the daughter's travel on the official guest list.
I can see answers to my prayers.
_________
Thanks for your comments over recent days, Dr Ongugo. You've been in splendid form - KJ
Posted by: Kindin Ongugo | 19 May 2023 at 12:29 AM
There is a case for thinking some (not all) politicians in PNG have less respect for the human citizens of PNG than the respect and affection toward Canadian Walrus Smooshie is receiving from former senior animal trainer Phil Demers.
Beware, heartwarming story:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65528793
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 18 May 2023 at 05:16 PM
Marape should repent of his bigotry and "render unto Caesar what is Caesar's", otherwise his words are as false as his political ideals.
How does it serve Take Back PNG if the country has an eminently incompetent, suspiciously affluent and morally questionable foreigner as Foreign Minister?
Or did Marape read that title literally, as he does the Bible?
Posted by: Michael Dom | 16 May 2023 at 04:33 PM
I have to agree with the writer. The painful processing of investigation would uncover the truth.
In today's The National newspaper, Marape reiterated his call for forgiveness for Tkatchenko.
The only rational for Marape reiterating this forgiveness call is to cover up his role in this saga.
If Marape does not want to fall on his sword his best trick would be to crucify Tkatchenko now.
Interesting few weeks ahead.
Posted by: Kindin Ongugo | 16 May 2023 at 12:14 PM
Racism in any direction is plainly wrong.
But if the Minister has no intention of constitutional application of equity, then the Minister is in need of attending retraining (thus time out) or being relegated to lesser standing, maybe ‘unseating’.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 15 May 2023 at 03:43 PM
Racism in any direction is an implication of ‘roundup’, like “all eggs in one basket.”
Plainly wrongly informing.
But if the Minister has no intention of constitutional application of equity, then the Minister is in need of attending retraining (thus time out) or being relegated to lesser standing, maybe ‘unseating’.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 15 May 2023 at 11:35 AM