Honour not glory is memorial’s aim
22 September 2024
PAUL OATES
CLEVELAND - It appears in the minds of a few detractors that the recognition of those who died in the service of Australia and Papua New Guinea has yet again been conflated with accusations of desire for personal aggrandisement.
The issues of recognition and aggrandisement or glory could not be clearer in my mind and they have always been separate.
At an event at the National Archives some years ago, we paid tribute to those many dedicated people who went before us and who continued to work to help Papua New Guinea progress into the modern world.
Those people who point out that this was what we were hired for are correct. Yet there is a whiff of angst over whether the efforts of these people deserve any form of recognition of service simply because they may never have been issued with a uniform.
As I have pointed out before to the blockers, this issue is irrelevant. If detractors deny the opportunity to recognise those who lost their lives, in many cases in dangerous situations, surely that’s a personal view and should be left to the individual.
Look at the example of Greg Harris’s sister not even knowing where her brother’s grave was or who was looking after it.
If there is to be some form of physical memorial to those who lost their lives due to their service, and there are plenty of other examples in Canberra, then surely there should be some form of explanation about what that service was about.
Clearly, no one in contemporary Australia has been educated about PNG’s history and our association with our Melanesian friends on the other side of the Torres Strait.
All the ventilating about who should get what is merely clouding an important issue. Australia and Australians were working with the Papua New Guinean people to constructively improve their circumstances and lives.
That aspect should surely not be erased from our shared history.
Whether anyone wants to have their service recognised with something tangible after all these years is a personal matter both separate and divisible from any planned memorial.
Comments