Wealthiest & saddest nation on earth
23 April 2025
PHILIP FITZPATRICK
TUMBY BAY, SA - We all know about inequity and the envy and jealousy it can create. History tells us that in extreme cases it can cause violence and even revolution.
At a macro level it is almost axiomatic that a downtrodden people will eventually rise up against their oppressors.
At a micro level, however, the envy and jealousy created by inequity can have different manifestations.
As Guardian columnist George Monbiot explains, a fundamental aspect of humanity includes “the urge to destroy that from which you feel excluded.”
This urge, the statistics tell us, is the cause of much crime. Cases of vandalism, arson, assault and even murder can appear to be senseless but, as Monbiot explains, marginalisation and insecurity are often the trigger for these crimes.
“At the root of some of these explanations, I feel, is something deeply embedded in the human psyche: if you can’t get even, get mean.”
In Papua New Guinea, if you have ever been the victim of raskols, you will understand what Monbiot is saying.
It would seem that mitigating inequity in society would be a logical panacea against such crimes and antisocial behaviour.
That is, until you dig a little deeper.
Prior to its colonisation the numerous tribal groups in Papua New Guinea were largely egalitarian with everyone, more or less, having equal rights.
Colonisation, however, introduced a stark contrast to this system in the form of the colonisers’ material wealth and power.
Observers quickly noted the rapid abandonment of traditional material culture by the local people and the take up of European goods in their place.
Who would want to keep an old stone axe when a vastly more efficient steel axe could be had in its place?
Who would cook food in a fragile earthenware pot or bamboo tube when a long lasting metal pot was available?
And thus the culture of advanced capitalism was introduced to Papua New Guinea. If you wanted those wonderful new things you had to earn money or trade goods to acquire them.
As I recall, selling priceless old stone axes and other artefacts to tourists and casual collectors for a pittance was common prior to independence. Sell grandad’s old adze and buy a shiny new steel one was the go.
And of course, with this new culture came the concept of inequity and the envy and jealousies entailed between those who could acquire this new material wealth and those who could not.
Thus, the rich and poor and the haves and have nots were created in Papua New Guinea where such distinctions had never existed before.
That is, the colonised, to all intents and purposes, became just like the colonisers.
What happened in PNG is exactly what happened in just about all the countries of the world that adopted capitalism.
The most savage form of capitalism was developed in the USA. American novelist, Kurt Vonnegut, explained how it works in his 1969 novel Slaughterhouse-Five.
“America is the wealthiest nation on Earth, but its people are mainly poor, and poor Americans are urged to hate themselves. To quote the American humourist Kin Hubbard, 'It ain’t no disgrace to be poor, but it might as well be.”
“….. Americans, like human beings everywhere, believe many things that are obviously untrue. Their most destructive untruth is that it is very easy for any American to make money. They will not acknowledge how in fact hard money is to come by, and, therefore, those who have no money blame and blame and blame themselves.
“This inward blame has been a treasure for the rich and powerful, who have had to do less for their poor, publicly and privately, than any other ruling class since, say, Napoleonic times. Many novelties have come from America. The most startling of these, a thing without precedent, is a mass of undignified poor. They do not love one another because they do not love themselves.”
The novel, by the way, is currently banned by many libraries in America.
Feeling inferior because you are poor appears to be a particular American invention.
As Vonnegut asserts, associating wealth with virtue is a cultural trait born out of the need for billionaires to justify their greed as virtue and a sign of their acumen.
Donald Trump seems to think it makes him a genius.
Elsewhere, it is recognised for what it is, a nasty addiction to greed minus compassion or empathy.
Outside America, billionaires and the vulgarly rich are often regarded with disdain and ridicule. In Australia we have Gina Rinehart and in PNG people have a whole bunch of obese politicians to laugh about.
There are signs, however, that things are beginning to change in America, thanks to Donald Trump and his billionaire friends.
The perception that the billionaire class have pushed capitalism to its most obscene limits is slowly taking shape.
What Monbiot is saying about getting even will therefore probably be another American phenomenon.
It will be interesting to watch.
More the lawless than rascal, is the word raskol.
From deeper in the sense of obnoxious, the word as written has usage in a very different nation, that of the Rus peoples.
The following paragraph is from a cleric mate of mine, and who had some years an appointed duty of visiting Russia.
Raskol is said to denote Old Believer schism, which survived both 1905 and 1917 Revolutions, [and] was referred to in the Russian language as ‘Raskol’.
It was significant that Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s character in “Crime & Punishment” was named ‘Raskolnikov’ (Расколниковь), literally meaning one who divides or breaks out, schizoid so to speak. Schism in the church is referred to in the same way.
A smidgen of coincidence in words is in that both societal locations of usage has at its base a severance of a cohort and 'cultural' intent and indeed practices.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 29 April 2025 at 08:52 AM
Of unremitting indoctrination (is that corruption of the gift of potential at intelligence?), there has occurred a massive event said to be the result of intense fires ... seen spreading between containers before the explosion ... a result of "improper handling of a shipment of solid fuel intended for use in Iranian ballistic missiles".
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0782l4yx78o
Raskolism is a subset of crime type that profligates where societal health is askew.
No less, a concentration on an intransigent indoctrination makes not for intelligent society spake.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 28 April 2025 at 10:42 AM
The United States of Amnesia was founded by some rather bright people although we haven’t seen them since.
Its current education crisis is somewhat foreboding and reminiscent of the curriculum in Nazi Germany throughout the 1930s.
A dystopian propaganda machine has degenerated into a pedagogy of repression that is relentlessly endorsed as patriotic education.
It has also rapidly deteriorated into a virtue of the vicious with a total disdain for spiritual values.
The vituperative sermons typically consist of a volatile cocktail littered with blame or fear, which are regularly punctuated with racism and bigotry.
Moreover, the homilies are frequently reinforced by intolerant and coercive religious zealots or sinister political and economic fundamentalists to boost compliance and guarantee conformity with the venomous ideology……
All in all you’re just another brick in the wall.
This unremitting indoctrination decays discernment or critical judgement, which extirpates communities of practice, renunciates wisdom and simultaneously suppresses social dialogue and destroys tacit knowledge or incidental learning.
It has eclipsed the public domain and turned light into shadow.
Distinguishing between lies and truth or fact from fiction becomes increasingly enigmatic and represents an existential threat to an already diaphanous or defective democracy.
A simple but distinctive ritual emerges involving the manufacture and embellishment of stories to induce panic, disorientation, hatred or fear.
The origin of these foibles is then relentlessly reinforced through intrigue, ideology or dogma.
Meanwhile, an appointed demagogue delivers inflammatory sermons that identify scapegoats, who are often minority groups and who inevitably endure the blame.
Indeed, the medium is the message. The meteoric rise of cable television and use of antisocial media platforms has undermined serious journalism with algorithmic audiencing and the social amplification or attenuation of risk.
This concocts consent and immerses the laity into a perpetual state of flux or vertigo that eviscerates the reality of experience and standards of thought, which affords a fertile environment for totalitarianism.
Posted by: Bernard Corden | 24 April 2025 at 01:07 PM
Trump pronouncements of Ukraine resistance against extraneous incursion likely only to extend his own sense of awww.
Posted by: Lindsay F Bond | 24 April 2025 at 12:25 PM
The late Leonard Cohen referred to the USA as the cradle of the best and the worst in the track entitled Democracy from The Future album:
https://youtu.be/RWjRPJdzbC8?si=LftG7G-qzCUI-Lsy
Many of the lyrics are prophetic.
The staggering inequality and inordinate emphasis on individualism with winners and losers that are entrenched in the US cultural psyche may also be a significant contributory factor in mass shootings and other horrendous gun crimes.
Posted by: Bernard Corden | 23 April 2025 at 09:34 PM
Good work Phil - Your piece satisfies questions arising from my interest in the people of the Pacific, notably my Motu mates and Australian originals and gives additional sources of information.
Posted by: Henry Sims | 23 April 2025 at 01:42 PM